Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Extent and Nature of Alignment Between Student and Teacher Perceptions of the Classroom

Fri, April 17, 4:05 to 5:35pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Northwestern/Ohio State

Abstract

Research has increasingly suggested that students’ perceptions of the classroom provide important information about teaching and teacher quality (Ferguson, 2012), yet little is known about whether teachers’ own perceptions of the classroom, drawn from many shared experiences, align to their students’. If students and teachers do perceive their classrooms differently, such misalignment may impede positive student-teacher relationships, which researchers have long argued is important for the quality of students’ classroom experiences (Brophy and Good, 1974; Pianta, 1999; Wentzel, 2009).
The few studies that have examined agreement between student and teacher perceptions of the classroom find little consensus, with some finding general agreement between students and teachers (Ben-Chaim & Zoller, 2001; Fisher & Rickards, 2000; Wubbels & Levy, 1991), and others disagreement, largely resulting from teachers’ positive overestimations as compared to students (Brekelmans, Mainhard, den Brok, & Wubbels 2011; den Brok, Brekelmans, & Wubbels, 2004). Beyond these, we have found little investigation or description of characteristics of classrooms where students and teachers disagreed. Thus, it remains unclear whether and to what extent misalignment does exist, and if so, what the causes and implications of such misalignment might be.
This study aims to add to this literature by investigating the degree of alignment between teachers’ and students’ perceptions of the classroom, and then describing the characteristics of misaligned versus aligned classrooms. Using student and teacher survey data from 433 upper-elementary classrooms we ask: (1) To what degree do teachers’ and students’ perceptions of classroom climate and organization agree? (2) What are the characteristics of classrooms where there is disagreement?
Results indicate that students’ and teachers perceptions’ of classroom climate and organization are moderately correlated, but stronger for organization (r=.49, p<.001) than for climate (r= .24, p<.001). We classified classrooms as misaligned when differences between students’ and teachers’ surveys scores differed by more than one standard deviation unit; roughly 25% of classrooms in our sample were thus categorized on either perceptions of the classroom climate or organization.
Logistic regression indicated that, for both climate and organization, classrooms with higher proportions of students eligible for subsidized lunches were more likely to be misaligned. Classrooms with higher proportions of African American students were more likely to be misaligned, but this likelihood decreased if these classrooms were also taught by an African American teacher. Similarly, classrooms with higher proportions of White students were less likely to be misaligned, but the likelihood of misalignment increased if the teacher in these classes was not also White. Finally, for perceptions of organization only, classrooms with greater proportions of male students were less likely to be misaligned, though the likelihood increased if the teacher was female.
These results suggest that alignment between student and teacher perceptions of the classroom may be influenced, in part, by other teacher and student characteristics and in particular, by alignment of students’ and teachers’ race and gender. These findings support den Brok’s, Wubbels, van Tarwijk, and Veldman’s (2010) work suggesting that students’ perceptions of classroom climate and organization may be influenced by ethnicity.

Authors