Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Internship is assumed to have an impact on student teachers’ learning, and student teachers tend to praise their field experiences as crucial in learning to teach. Previous research has found that novice teachers tend to be more preoccupied with their own lesson plans and surviving, rather than being concerned with what their pupils understand and learn (Richardson & Placier 2001, Edward and Protheroe 2003). Some studies show, however, that effective programs give student teachers theoretical grounded tools to use in the classroom (Darling-Hammond et al 2005, Darling-Hammond 2006), and Feiman – Nemser (2001) argues for the need to develop a ‘beginning repertoire’ for prospective teachers including certain techniques in classroom management. To provide them with tools that can help them to master the complexities in teaching is thus advocated for.
This presentation is a comparison of mentoring conversations during student teachers’ field work. What do mentors and student teachers talk about during mentoring sessions, what seem to be dominating topics? What do student teachers possibly learn by taking part in these conversations?
The empirical material is video-recorded mentoring sessions (54) among teacher students and mentor teachers in practice schools in a Business-as-usual condition and in a Lesson study intervention. Mentoring sessions in these two conditions are analyzed through the use of ‘thin descriptions’ (Riviera & Tharp 2004). Based on an inductive approach to the empiric material different categories for content in mentoring sessions have been developed. These categories are then used deductively in analyses of all mentoring sessions in both conditions.
Analyses of mentoring sessions from the Business-as-usual condition (30) show that task oriented topics are dominating, while pupil oriented and subject oriented references are scarce. Attention is focused on student teachers’ ‘doings’, and little awareness of pupils’ learning can be depicted. Analyses of mentoring sessions from the Lesson study intervention (24) show a shift of focus from ‘doings’ to a greater awareness of pupils’ understanding and learning. The systematic observations of, and interviews with selected pupils in the Lesson Study intervention seem to have contributed to this change of focus. Both of these seem to function as tools that support student teachers’ understanding and analyses of classroom complexities. The observed changes can suggest that novice teachers’ preoccupation with surviving and deliverers of their lesson plans (Richardson and Placier 2001) are not inevitable trajectories in their professional development, and that concerns for pupils’ growth and learning can to a certain extent be stimulated by alternative ways of organizing and preparing internship.
If mentoring is to enhance student teachers’ professional development, mentors need to direct the attention of student teachers towards the most important aspects of teaching, namely pupils’ and their understanding and learning. Lesson Study as a framework that stimulates and support student teachers’ learning to teach is discussed and also the responsibility of teacher education institutions to provide common frameworks both for teacher students and teacher educators at campus and on practice schools.
Nina Helgevold, University of Stavanger
Gro Naesheim-Bjorkvik, University of Stavanger
Sissel Østrem, University of Stavanger