Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

"Her Choice": Neoliberal Obstacles to Understanding Consent, Rape, and Objectification in a Sex Education Classroom

Thu, April 16, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Hyatt, Floor: West Tower - Silver Level, Dusable

Abstract

Objectives
This research presents a discourse analysis of classroom discussions in 7 9th grade sex education classrooms. We explore how a neoliberal discourse intersects with a discourse of autonomy and personal choice in the sex education/sexual ethics classroom and presents obstacles to students’ growth in critical consciousness around an ethic of care, understanding gendered relationships, and reflecting on how background conditions constrain autonomy.

Perspectives
Current evidence-based sex education programs are health and risk-focused, necessitating an approach that emphasizes individual choice and self-care (Lamb, 2010; 2013). The SECS-C (Sexual Ethics for a Caring Society Curriculum) is an applied philosophy curriculum that aims to put sex education in a social context, teaching students to treat others ethically and understand social circumstances in which sexual relationships and sex in society is expressed.

Most sex education is situated within a neoliberal project wherein responsibility for the self is “carried to new heights” (Bay-Cheng, 2012). Neoliberalism, according to Apple, places choice-making at the center of democratic freedom in a situation in which people don’t have equal opportunity to make choices (Apple, 2001). This neoliberal discourse emphasizes individual choices and ignores social conditions under which actors act and agents make choices (Apple, 2001; Bay-Cheng & Eliseo-Arras, 2008; McAvoy, 2013; Sonu, 2012).

Methods
In this paper we explore several ethical dialogues (Kunzman, 2006) that occurred during three semesters in which the SECS-C was taught to 9th graders. Through a discourse analysis, we explore the positions of students regarding sex education topics as they adhere to the neoliberal perspective of choice during opportunities in the class to engage in a discussion that focused less on individual choice and more on care for others or changing society.

Data sources

The students were a diverse group, 75% of them with parents who are immigrants from the Caribbean, Africa, Central America, and South America. Most were students of color.

Recordings from five 9th grade classes were transcribed and researchers reviewed transcripts and used a constructivist discourse analytic technique (Braun & Clarke, 2006) to explore themes and discourses.

Results

In this paper we discuss three themes. The first specifically addresses the neoliberal discourse in the classroom around consent. The second addresses girls of color’s vulnerability in the sex education classroom and their discursive resistance in discussions that positioned girls as potential victims. We discuss this resistance with reference to the “politics of respectability” (Higginbotham, 1992) intersecting with the neoliberal discourse. The third addresses a discourse around hopelessness with regard to changing society and gendered relations.

Scholarly significance

When sex education is supported as a part of democratic civics education, using practical philosophy and/or ethics as a guide, such a curriculum can also address the marginalization of certain groups, problematic stereotypes, and the culture’s confusing messages about sex in society. However, there are overlapping discourses about personal responsibility relating to gender, race, culture and a neoliberal context that present obstacles to students’ moving from a position of self-protection to a position of care and concern for others and for society at large.

Authors