Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Border Relations: Ethics and Purposes of Ethnology and Meta-Ethnography

Mon, April 11, 7:45 to 9:15am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 146 B

Abstract

The larger epistemological project of comparative ethnography requires critical interrogation of the ethics and purpose of comparative work; an understanding of methodologies, and deliberation about the translatability and commensurability of that which is being compared (Thorne et al., 2004). Notably, comparative ethnographic projects cannot escape the colonial origins of ethnography and the potential for colonial, post-colonial and anti-colonial relations in the comparisons being made. For ethnographies presented in this symposium, “US Parochialism” is a key feature of ‘border relations.’ For example, comparing ethnographies from Mexico and the United States invites an interrogation of how each national context is embedded in the other. Mexico, of course, has been subject to US policy and intervention since its founding and the politics of race and education in the United States is, in part, about the US dominance in the bilateral relation between Mexico and the United States. Canadian-US comparisons have a different history but the different colonial histories of these two nations are still played out in everyday life in each nation, their educational systems and the bilateral relations between the nations. Thus comparing ethnographies across such borders is about knowing how ‘border relations’ are embedded in the respective ethnographies.

There are two basic approaches to comparative ethnography, ethnology and meta-ethnography, and both are challenged by ‘border reactions’ being embedded in ethnographies. For ethnology, the goal of a greater understanding has been linked to Western dominance (Marcus and Fisher, 1986). That is, building a better ethnology is also building dominion over what knowledge counts. Meta-ethnography (Noblit and Hare, 1988) was a response to this and was situated less as generalized understandings and more about particularities, creating analogies between ethnographies. Thirty years later both ethnology and meta-ethnography are both less critical and less informed by ‘border relations’ than necessary in today’s globalized world.

This presentation is a conceptual, theoretical and methodological discussion on conducting comparative ethnographies that is suspicious of the pursuit of generalized understandings of ethnology and sees the analogic approach of meta-ethnography as lacking a full engagement with ‘border relations’ in comparative ethnographies. Engaging border relations fully requires both contextualizing each ethnography in the comparison in terms of the other and with alternative ‘perspective taking.’ This “perspective taking’ involves seeing a second (or more) ethnography from the perspective of a first ethnography and then reversing this view. Contextualization and perspective taking create a radically different basis for comparative ethnography.

Authors