Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Migration and Education in the United States and Argentina: Examining Concepts of Assimilation and Inclusion

Mon, April 11, 7:45 to 9:15am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 146 B

Abstract

The sustained and, in some cases, increased levels of international migration have led to a serious concern with the education of immigrant children and youth. Faced with these changes, different countries are developing political discourses and social policies to plan and regulate the presence of migrants. Research on the phenomenon has also increased. While the education of immigrant children has been a target of research for decades in the United States it has recently become a relevant topic of research in South America.

This paper proposes to compare studies of migration and education in the United States and Argentina, focusing on the scope and limits of the perspectives of assimilation, a term used widely in the United States, and the parallel notion of inclusion, more common in South America. Our paper focuses on two cases: Mexican migration in the United States, and Bolivian migration in Argentina.

We first take up some of the political, sociological, and anthropological debates regarding assimilation and inclusion. We then identify lines of ethnographic research in both contexts, showing how educational ethnography problematizes existing categories and concepts. We argue that the educational experiences of immigrant youth and children demonstrate the limits of the concepts of assimilation and inclusion, which are so present in broader social discourses. At the same time, we consider the distinct modalities of inclusion/exclusión being produced in schools, resulting in what might be called subordinated inclusion marked by inequality. Overall, the paper emphasizes the potential and complexity of a comparative approach to understand migratory dynamics and the impact of migration on national educational systems.

Authors