Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In this paper, we aim to present a panorama of research on indigenous childhoods, drawing connections and contrasts among recent ethnographic works from three countries: Argentina, Brazil, and the United States. This selection of national contexts derives from two circumstances. These three countries share certain characteristics that exert a powerful influence on both the indigenous populations within their borders and on the ethnographic research traditions pertaining therein. First, each has a population that is, at least by official measures, less than 2 percent indigenous, lower than most other countries within the continental Americas. Secondly, they represent three of the four largest national economies in the hemisphere (the third largest being Mexico, whose unique circumstances with respect to indigenous groups implies a rather different set of challenges). Consequently, although the indigenous people are present in the national imagination of the three countries (perhaps especially in Brazil, because of global conservation initiatives in the Amazon), state policies devote scant attention to the rights and demands of indigenous groups. Because of this situation, ethnographic research is one of the few channels by which knowledge about indigenous societies filters into the larger non-indigenous population, which for the most part gives little thought to the continued existence of such groups.
With these clarifications concerning the scope of our reflections, we propose to analyze some common threads among these three nations, regarding the thematic foci of recent research on indigenous childhoods and (within the larger framework of the anthropology of education) the theoretical and methodological approaches guiding that research. Indeed, there have been parallel movements in Argentina, Brazil and the United States in the last 20 years. We see increasing focus on the presence of indigenous children in schools—where Brazilian scholars ask, among other things, how indigenous children appropriate school for their own uses. We also see a new focus on the everyday education of indigenous children both inside and outside schools, recovering the broad anthropological understanding of the notion of “education.”
At the same time, we will examine how the particularities of each national context, and of the specific cultural groups contained therein, have shaped research agendas in each case. For example, US ethnographers have studied indigenous children in the United States but also elsewhere, in the tradition of anthropological studies of the exotic. In contrast, in Brazil and Argentina, where anthropology developed after de-colonization, it is assumed that anthropologists study their own country. In addition, whereas most US ethnography on indigenous children is written in traditional academic mode, countries like Brazil have a long tradition of dialogue between academic researchers and the institutions of civil society, and hence ethnographers write and present findings in a wider variety of formats.
Finally, we note the impact of global contexts. Given that the global academy has centers of power, from which a written scientific production almost exclusively in English disseminates, there is little receptivity to the extensive body of research coming from researchers who write in Spanish or Portuguese, much less in indigenous languages.