Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Independent E-Book Reading at School: Online Program Quality and Influence on Reading Development

Mon, April 11, 7:45 to 9:45am, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Four, Independence Salon G

Abstract

Purpose
In 2002, the National Reading Panel report downgraded the benefits of sustained silent reading time at school, having found little scientific research to support effects on students’ reading achievement. Recent reports, however, point to value-added of independent reading at school for improving reading skills and motivation to read (Picton, 2014). Access to e-books has revived independent reading as a potent mechanism for reading improvement. Opportunity to build a personal reading collection coupled with dashboard feedback piques students’ interests. Instant, actionable data of students’ e-book reading available to teachers increases the potential of independent reading for instruction. This study compares the effects of e-book independent reading on primary graders’ fluency and comprehension skills in two different online reading programs. Differences in e-book choice may be a critical factor in realizing the benefits of e-book independent reading.
Perspectives
Correlational studies (out-of-school reading) show that the amount of independent reading students do significantly influences their level of reading performance (e.g., Anderson, Fielding & Wilson, 1988). Research syntheses of in-school independent reading describe common elements of successful programs: good books, role models, time, student choice (Flowers & Roos, 1994). Only 33% of students, however, say their class has a designated time for independent books and only 17% say it occurs daily (Scholastic, 2015). Yet e-book reading has almost doubled and students report they would read more if they had access to e-books. E-reading also offers an opportunity to attract and motivate boys and reluctant readers to read more books. Even a small amount of independent reading helps increase students’ reading comprehension, vocabulary growth, spelling ability, understanding of grammar, and knowledge of the world Allington, 2009; Cunningham & Stanovich, 2001). This points to the need for more independent reading at school, especially with e-books.
Method
Using a between subjects design, an 8-week study in two primary level classrooms in an urban school (majority African-American) is underway. Independent Reading Time (IRT) occurs 20 minutes each day following an IRT structure. A total of 80 students are involved. Students are randomly assigned to either the Raz Kids or Storia IRT condition. Measures include data dashboard metrics, DIBELS progress monitoring probes (pre/post), GORT-5 comprehension (pre/post), IRT interviews and a teacher fidelity checklist.
Results
Results are currently pending. Based on a pilot study we project substantial increases in number of books read, time spent reading and engagement for all students in both programs. Fluency and comprehension are also projected to increase for below benchmark readers in both programs with Storia having a slight advantage over Raz Kids in comprehension. Early evidence suggests students prefer Raz Kids for ease of use and Storia for title selections. Teacher fidelity to the IRT structure is promising.
Significance
Daily IRT with access to e-books may boost reading volume, which in turn develops fluency and comprehension skills, especially for reluctant and struggling readers. Selection of digital reading program may have implications for successful IRT at school.

Author