Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Provincializing English: Race, Empire, and English Teacher Identities

Sat, April 9, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Three, Union Station

Abstract

In this analysis of the interrelatedness of race, “empire,” English, and schooling, I argue that educators have historically underestimated the powerful ways in which practices of English teaching and the mechanics of the ‘global English teaching industry’ create constructions of English-teacher identity that produce particular conceptions of English speaker, colonialism, and “empire.” This analysis illuminates how the status quo in teaching unwittingly sustains racial inequalities in K-12 schooling of immigrant children, and how it contributes—albeit invisibly—to an enduring, global set of inequalities.

This paper combines three broad sets of theories, those examining formations of race (Omi and Winant, 2015; Stam and Shohat, 2012), “empire,” (an umbrella term I use to support my understanding of the parallel processes of post-colonialism, globalization, neoliberalism—e.g., Hardt and Negri, 2000; Chakarabarty, 2000), and linguistic identities, including constructions of nativeness (Lurda and Moussu, 2010, Matsuda, 2014). While these three sets of theories derive from different disciplinary moorings, their interconnectedness provides fertile ground for this present analysis.

My study comes from the tradition of qualitative meta-analysis (McCormick, Rodney and Varcoe, 2003), and knits together disciplinary conventions not often put into conversation with each other while also drawing from a multiplicity of studies by a range of theorists, including those who examine teacher identity (Participant, 2005; Participant, 2008; Curtis and Romney, 2006, Participant, 2015); race and TESOL (Kubota and Lin, 2009; Ruecker and Ives, forthcoming; Motha, 2014; Golombek and Jordan, 2005); empire (Edge, 2006; Kumaravadivelu, forthcoming); neoliberalism (Block, Gray, and Holborow; 2021; Chun, 2015); multilingualism (Blackledge and Creese, 2010; Garcia and Wei, 2014; Flores, 2013); translingual practices (Canagarajah, 2013, Pennycook, 2015), and native-speaker identity (Mahboob, 2010; Shin, 2008). These many intersecting theoretical traditions are integrated to form the conceptual argument I present in my paper.

The historical trajectory of English language dissemination—transmitted primarily from speakers coded as “White” to learners considered “non-White”—has left a legacy in which constructions of “English” are dependent on unequal racial and colonial formations. The concept of “English learners,” then, is predicated on a construction of “English teachers” that serves as a juxtaposition, as a foil, an imagined endpoint. In this equation, teachers’ bodies become important, with the English language and its associated ideologies becoming literally embodied in its teachers and helping to create the logic for the profession. In my paper I used these views of how language constructs identity to examine notions of ways that English teacher constructs the professional and personal identities of the teachers who step into this role and form concomitant relationships with their non-English speaking students. As a result, I discuss how, by becoming more aware of this power-laden structure of identity, language, and status, new teachers can construct professional identities that are liberating, not oppressing, and can re-construct the binary between English teacher and English learner.

Author