Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Emotionally Intelligent Teaching: What Is It and How Do We Measure It?

Tue, April 12, 8:15 to 9:45am, Convention Center, Floor: Level Three, Ballroom A

Abstract

Purpose: We discuss the concept of emotionally intelligent teaching and present pilot data from a newly developed measure: The Emotionally Intelligent Teaching Checklist (EITC).
Perspective/Theoretical Framework: Young children’s social-emotional (SE) skills are foundational to their social and academic success, which is why social-emotional learning (SEL) is a critical component of high-quality early childhood education (e.g., Durlak et al., 2015). However, many teachers do not feel adequately equipped to effectively teach SE skills (Zinsser et al., 2015). Although SEL interventions have been developed, many do not directly measure the ‘black box’ of SEL pedagogy leaving this essential process unknown and overlooked.
An emotionally intelligent classroom includes (1) attachment between educators and children (Bergin & Bergin, 2009), (2) modeling and support (Denham et al., 2012), (3) developmentally appropriate direct teaching of emotional intelligence (Copple & Bredekamp, 2009; Rivers et al., 2013). Although the Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS; see Howes et al., 2008) measures qualities associated with safety, trust, and support, as well as engaging in effective practice, the CLASS was not designed or intended to measure the direct teaching of SE skills. The EITC was designed to fill this gap in measurement and to augment the CLASS.
We propose a theory of change (Figure 1) demonstrating that (a) educators impact children’s SEL via emotionally intelligent pedagogy; (b) emotionally intelligent pedagogy is bidirectional with educators’ perceptions, knowledge, and beliefs; (c) there is a feedback loop between educators’ emotional intelligence and children’s SEL; and (d) educators’ emotional intelligence is the proximal target of intervention.
Methods: The EITC was created through (a) content analysis of an existing self-report measure; (b) comparisons to measures of related constructs (e.g., classroom climate); (c) anecdotal and structured note-taking in classrooms exploring content, frequency, and protocol; and (d) meetings with SEL experts. Pilot testing was conducted by two research assistants (RAs) in 24 classrooms at five schools. RAs took anecdotal notes about (a) what they saw relative to indicators, (b) their feedback for improvement of the measure, and (c) whether the EITC captured their own conceptualization of emotionally intelligent teaching.
Results: Pilot data revealed normally distributed scores with adequate variability (M=.35, SD=.21, Range=.00-.83, Skewness=0.34, Kurtosis=2.26). There were no significant differences between RAs on scores. EITC scores were correlated with average CLASS scores (r(22)=.36) and dimensions within emotional support (rs(22)=-.36-.40), classroom organization (rs(22)=.27-.41), and instructional support (rs(22)=.07-.50). Schools explained 44% of the variance in EITC scores and were significantly different, F(4,20)=5.01, η2=.51s. Anecdotally, RAs reported that the EITC can be completed with minimal training after CLASS coding and was face valid.
Scholarly Significance: Although our results are promising, there still remain many questions unanswered. Sufficient data are needed to fully test the validity, reliability, and usability of the EITC. In time, our hope is to validate an operationalization of teaching SE skills that is (a) grounded in theory (b) is easy for researchers and educators to use, (c) measures specific practices, (d) highlights areas for improvement, and (e) aids examinations of the “value-added” benefit of teaching SE skills.

Authors