Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The objective of this paper is to highlight the agentic social processes and subject positions young children enacted in their fantasy play in ways that challenge the child centered pedagogical structures within the early childhood classroom.
The way that teachers, researchers and theorists understand play lacks theoretical attention necessary to access the social world of children. This understanding emphasizes stage theories of development and socio-cultural theory that “assume(s) linearity, universal human behavior, unidirectional progress, and standards of normalcy” (Cannella, 1997 p.124). A Critical Childhood Studies lens challenges the understanding of children’s play through development and socialization and understands children as “active in the construction and determination of their own lives, the lives around them and of the societies in which they live” (Prout & James, 1990). Children are not only facilitating cultural reproduction but also cultural production within their play culture (James & James, 2008).
In order to fully understand the social processes and subjectivities that the children enacted in their fantasy play culture it is necessary to contextualize their play in relation to the dominant discourses of Developmentally Appropriate Practice and child centered pedagogy that shaped the larger classroom structures from which their play is situated. To understand how the children make sense of and resist this practice, I draw upon Anthropologist Brian Sutton-Smith’s rhetorics of play focusing on play as power and identities. Issues of power and identity are often overlooked and given little attention in their application to young children. Embracing the notion of power and identities in play allows for a conceptual opening for children and teachers to explore “identities and desires, and consider questions of voice and power in the classroom”(Rogers, 2011 p.15).
This paper utilizes ethnographic data collected in an urban daycare center with children 3-5 years old. The qualitative methodology allowed the exploration of context, meaning-making, storytelling, and specific classroom and playground experiences of young children. Central to my analysis is the use of constructed play vignettes that were created out of observations and audiotaped epsiodes of play. Erickson (1983) discusses the narrative vignette which “has functions that are rhetorical, analytical and evidentiary,” and which play a vital role in organizing the cultural and social patterns in the data (p.150).
I will focus on the ways children challenged Developmentally Appropriate discourses when they resisted the limits of the physical arrangement of the classroom in their play episodes; co-opted instructional materials and supplies; enacted fantasy subjectivities to reject classroom routines; and adapted instructional practices for their own agenda utilizing play artifacts.
This paper offers an empirical contribution to the field of Critical Childhood Studies. Fantasy play is a valuable opportunity for child-focused research that enables insight into young children’s agency. Because children’s voices are dismissed in the political area the many places where children’s agency is performed must be recognized. Ethnographies of children’s play are an often an underappreciated context in which to explore children’s agency and the experience of childhood.