Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Promise Delivered: Experiences and Outcomes of Historically Black College and University Alumni

Sat, April 9, 8:15 to 9:45am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 149 B

Abstract

Objectives: Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) are under attack. Critics question the relevancy of HBCUs due to their racial composition, arguing these institutions are incapable of meeting the needs of citizens in a “post-racial” society (Brown, 2013). What perhaps is more damaging is public opinion about whether these institutions provide students with the training and experiences that will make them competitive for graduate school and career opportunities. This backlash may be a result of the lack of literature on the experiences and outcomes of HBCU collegians and the belief that HBCUs represent a monolithic institutional group (Freeman & Thomas, 2002; Gasman, 2008). Thus, the purpose of this study was to gain a better understanding of how HBCUs promote opportunity and success for its students.

Theoretical Framework: This study’s design was informed by Astin’s (1993) Inputs-Environment-Output College Impact Model and an extensive review of literature in the areas of student experiences (e.g. Berger & Millem, 2000; Fleming, 1984) and college environments (e.g. Flowers, Scott, Riley & Palmer, 2015; Outcalt & Skewes-Cox, 2002).

Methods: This study follows a qualitative research design to addresses the following research questions: Which experiences, practices, and policies promote student retention within the context of an HBCU? And what experiences, practices, and policies do HBCU alumni attribute to their postsecondary success?

Data Sources, evidence, objects, or materials Data is drawn from semi-structured interviews with 53 participants across 21 institutions. Fifty-one participants identified as African American and two participants as Caucasian. Thirty participants were female and 23 participants were male. All participants completed their bachelor’s degree between the year 2000 and 2011. Each participant completed a demographic questionnaire and engaged in an individual audio-recorded 60-90 minute interview via telephone. Following a step-by-step process of analyzing the transcripts, I began with open coding of the data and subsequently grouped them into tentative categories of data representing the emergent themes that addressed the research question (Merriam, 2009).

Results: Findings highlight the lasting impact of HBCU staff and faculty on the personal and professional outcomes of HBCU alumni. These individuals were described as “parents,” “big brothers/sisters,” or simply role models for success. They structured opportunities for participants to gain personal confidence, professional experiences through internships, or fostered connections that lead to jobs or graduate school enrollment. Additionally, findings highlight the experiences and practices that promote persistence and graduation across all participants in the study, despite initial differences in students’ SES and precollege academic achievement.

Significance: Few empirical studies have sought to specifically understand the undergraduate experiences of HBCU graduates and those experiences that contribute to institutional retention and degree attainment. Because HBCUs are not a monolithic group, this can only be accomplished through cross-sectional research that solicits the voice of a diverse array of HBCU graduates. This paper highlights this perspective, providing insights into how to foster institutional policies and practices to successfully recruit and retain the 21st century student.

Author