Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teaching for Equity: How Classroom Interactions Influence Achievement

Tue, April 12, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 144 C

Abstract

This paper addressed the problem of the opportunity gap, or “the accumulated differences in access to key educational resources” (Darling-Hammond, 2010, p. 28), by examining hypothesized teaching practices that open opportunities for all students to engage in meaningful classroom interactions. These hypothesized practices, (1) providing access, (2) supporting agency, authority, and identity, (3) developing high quality relationships, and (4) fostering intersubjectivity, have yet to be brought together to observe everyday classroom interactions in urban settings or to be linked to student achievement. We investigate the influence of these equitable teaching practices on student achievement. Specifically, we ask: What is the relation between teachers’ enactment of equitable teaching practices, student participation, and student achievement?

Drawing on research from the fields of mathematics and urban education, this study brings together two theories of effective teaching, the Teaching for Robust Understanding (TRU) Framework (TRU Math; Schoenfeld, 2014) and the Asset-Focused Instructional Strategies framework (Boykin & Noguera, 2011), to investigate how teachers construct opportunities to engage in meaningful classroom interactions. The TRU Math structured our examination of teachers’ facilitation of student participation (i.e., who gets to participate and how they get to participate). More specifically, we measured the extent to which teachers (a) provided equal access to meaningful mathematics for all students and (b) supported the development of positive mathematical identities. The Asset-Focused framework structured our examination of the presence of classroom factors that have been found to more broadly support motivation to learn, including the extent to which teachers (c) engage in positive relationships with students, and (d) foster intersubjectivity in their classrooms.

Using the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) Longitudinal Database, we analyzed a video subsample of 42 6th-8thgrade teachers. We employed micro-level video coding methods to obtain scores for each classroom on the Access to Mathematical Content and Agency, Authority and Identity scales of the TRU Math and on a researcher- developed coding scheme instantiating two Asset- Focused Factors: positive interpersonal relationships and fostering intersubjectivity.

In preliminary analysis of twelve classrooms, wide variation exists in teachers’ use of equitable teaching practices with classrooms with high value-added scores on a conceptually- based math achievement test displaying more equitable teaching practices than low value-added classrooms on average for providing access (M= 1.94, SD = .53; M = 1.83, SD = .19, respectively), supporting positive mathematical identities (M = 1.56, SD = .75; M = 1.24, SD = .33), and developing positive interpersonal relationships (M = 1.11, SD = .37; M = .83, SD = .2). In next steps we will test variations in enactment of and associations between equitable teaching practices and teachers’ value-added scores.

This paper builds an empirical basis for claims that equitable teaching practices may productively reduce the opportunity gap that persists in U.S. schools. Our results add specificity by examining how the ways in which students are supported to participate in mathematical activities might matter. We discuss how future research and intervention work aimed at supporting teachers might benefit from shifted attention to adolescent experiences and the roles that students are afforded in classrooms.

Authors