Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Reframing Teachers' Action in Curriculum Poststructural Research in Times of Neoliberal Policies

Tue, April 12, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Four, Treasury

Abstract

Theoretical Framework: In Brazil, as in many countries, curriculum policies have been criticized for enacting neoliberal principles and reshaping public demands in a network where private agents create new forms of governamentability (Ball, 2012, 2013). The concept of governamentability pursues the linkage between the political rationality of these new forms of “government” in schools and the ethical constitution of the subject -- which is my main concern here. Using post-structural (Foucault, 1990; Derrida, 2008) and post-colonial (Bhabha, 1994) theories, I focus on the action-researcher/educator as “the subject,” who both “acts” and is acted upon. How do audit-culture assumptions and discourses deeply limit the agency of the action-researcher? How might action-researchers utilize slippages in dominant business-oriented discourses in order to engage in principled resistance against such technical-rational forms of educating and researching?
Objective: This presentation explores the notion of action and agency in a neoliberal political context, trying to reframe the idea of action research in relation to post-structural theories in order to deal with threats to action researcher-teachers’ abilities to enact opportunities to “take action in the world.”
Modes of Inquiry: Referencing post-colonial and post-structural literature, I theorize how teachers’ agency can be broadly understood in contexts of shifting power that seeks to saturate education with measurable versions of teaching, learning and research. I apply my chosen theoretical lenses to interpret data produced in different action-research projects in schools in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, where the implementation of centralized curriculum policies supporting high stakes testing have been mostly responsible for reducing teachers’ agency in classrooms as well as in any forms of action-research. These data derive mainly from ethnographically oriented action-research, and will inform my discussion about how critical professional subjectivity can be produced in a over-normalized space, a place of power that also produces possibilities for agency (Butler, 2005).
Conclusion: Analyzing colonial power in post-structural terms, Bhabha (1994) gives emphasis to its ambivalence as he describes a power that spreads, counting on strong mechanisms of conscious and unconscious maintenance. Power’s force, paradoxically, resides in its ambivalence. That insight will help me to reframe action and agency in relation to action research and this panel’s stated goals of working toward forms of principled resistance as critical professionals. I work to conceptualize agency as located in the fissures and slippages between dominant market-driven discourses and practices that have infiltrated education, writ large, and those contingent moments in which power hierarchies are established and are able to be disrupted at the same time -- what Bhabha calls the third space. This requires recognition of difference. Thus, action researchers’ agency, in general, rests on the capacity of rearticulating, remodeling, and creating hybrid and contingent spaces for political daily struggle.
Significance: Post-structural political analyses have been accused of de/under politizicing educational scenes, by not focusing on how subjects can act against power. This paper argues that the post-structural turn is not about giving agency away but reframing it as an always on-going agency that operates, within power relations, on its ambivalences.

Author