Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Making a Right at the Intersection of Diagnosis and Culture: Examining Diagnostic Disparity in Learning Disability

Fri, April 8, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level Two, Exhibit Hall D Section C

Abstract

1. Objective

This presentation will explore patterns of diagnostic disparity in learning disability (LD) experienced by African American children. We will present the hypothesis that African American children may experience diagnostic disparity due to a complex constellation of factors including issues of differential diagnosis of children growing up in poverty, problems of cultural bias in assessment instruments, and usage of culturally devalued dialects and communication styles.

2. Perspective

Understanding the relationship between cultural expectations and diagnostic labels is not trivial. It is a key first question when we attempt to evaluate the extent to which a diagnosis is (1) a property of individuals (e.g., individuals have intellectual disabilities if their cognitive ability is below a certain level), as opposed to being (2) a property of cultures (e.g., American culture has scripted levels of participation and expectation for individuals that are, in part, based on intellectual ability), or (3) an interaction between individuals and their cultures (individuals who have certain cognitive profiles tend to be labeled with intellectual disabilities in American culture, and their roles in American culture change accordingly).

If one accepts the first position, then the causes, outcomes, and intervention efforts surrounding a disorder diagnosis will be fundamentally influenced by the assumption that diagnoses represent real labels for constellations of individual properties (cognition, behavior, emotion, and social participation). Similarly, if one accepts the second position, then the causes, outcomes, and intervention efforts surrounding a disorder diagnosis will be fundamentally influenced by the assumption that diagnosis represents culturally sanctioned limits for the roles an individual may fulfill in his or her culture.

Perhaps, in practice, many of us take a position allowing for diagnoses to be formed by interactions between individuals and their cultures. The fact that diagnoses change over time is enough to make many clinicians question their validity as constructs. The fact that certain individuals tend to experience diagnostic disparities compounds our doubts about diagnostic validity. However, perhaps most perplexing of all, is the notion of differential diagnosis, the idea that certain diagnostic categories may overlap to the extent that differentiating between them becomes arduous and subject to clinical debate.

3. Method and Results

We explore our hypothesis with diagnostic, cognitive, and communication data for a group of elementary school-aged, African American children. Results indicate both under and over-identification, highlighting the complexity inherent in diagnosis.

4. Scholarly Significance

Our concepts of disorder and our rubrics for diagnosing disorder represent culturally determined expectations about normal and acceptable cognition, behavior, emotion, and community participation that change over time. To the extent that an individual does not conform to these expectations, that individual will be labeled with a disability or disorder that fundamentally changes the nature of his or her participation in our culture. Thus, disability and disorder are culturally dependent constructions, existing to represent cultural norms that change and fluctuate as cultures evolve. Changes in terminology reflect changes in our cultural parameters of normalcy, our understanding of causes for abnormalcy, and our diagnostic criteria for categorizing individuals as normal or abnormal.

Authors