Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Pedagogical Sites for Sexuality Education: Moving on From School to Test the Limits of Possibility

Sat, April 9, 8:15 to 10:15am, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Four, Liberty Salon M

Abstract

Sexuality education (SE) teachers in the USA are the only officially sanctioned voice in schools charged with teaching students about sexuality and gender. Despite governmental mandates, there exists little consistency, or guidance for teachers (Eisenberg et al. 2010). One form, abstinence-only education, is ineffective in preventing pregnancy or delaying sexual intercourse (Crooks & Baur 2011). In contrast, comprehensive SE increases students’ sexual knowledge while not increasing sexual behavior (Perrin & DeJoy 2003). Effective approaches to the latter include reaction papers, tasteful humor, group discussions, and viewing erotic-based educational and entertainment media (eg Marsar et al. 2012). This curriculum appears more complete than previous approaches to learning about sex from peers, parents, media, or online (Rutledge et al. 2011). The third, and most prevalent form of SE, is silence where topics such as sexual activity, practices, identities and attitudes, remain ‘steeped in conceptions of moral purity and pollution’ (Tupper 2014, 155).

School spaces, invested as they are in regulatory systems of power, enforce gender and sexual conformity. Educators contributing to the (re)production of these systems (Mayo 2013; Payne & Smith 2013; Rasmussen 2006) marginalize gender and sexual diversity (Meyer 2009; Payne 2007; Talburt & Steinberg 2000) and regulate via ‘mundane and day-to-day processes and practices’ (Youdell 2006, 13). Anti-queer bullying is prevalent, with teachers and students both complicit (Kosciw et al. 2011). Furthermore, teachers facing significant barriers in addressing homophobic or heterosexist bullying (Meyer, 2008). While the USA is limited in comprehensive SE, other countries framing sexual health as an issue of physical, mental and social wellbeing (Nielsen, Paasonen & Spisak 2015) still have insufficient SE. (Kontula 2010). A lack of education, support and clear direction in curriculum implementation and the fear of tackling controversial topics fuels teachers’ anxieties about teaching SE (Carrion & Jensen 2014; Johnson, Sendall, & McCuaig, 2014; Shannon & Smith, 2015).

Why charge schools with SE when they hardly support such curriculum, fail to promote appropriate climates or sufficiently equip pedagogues? As online pornography increasingly becomes default curriculum, students exploit the autonomy and diversity of information through social media and online technology. Online platforms facilitate sexual exploration, play and learning, (Nielsen, Paasonen & Spisak, 2015) while youth-led video-making has allowed them to discuss sexuality interests and concerns, and develop guiding principles for their sexual behavior (Yang & MacEntee, 2015). As health, body, relationship issues, and sexuality have a central place in youth culture, public discourse and online environments (Dunkels, Franberg, & Hallgren, 2010; Powell, 2010) it seems a fourth space and form of SE remains essentially dormant.

Drawing on digital sources, this theoretical paper takes stock of the limits and affordances of a more radical approach to SE. I argue that the precarious and limited set of SE plateaus require challenge. Without explicit pedagogical and curriculum attention to comprehensive SE by well-resourced and informed teachers, and attention to deep cultural change in schools related to gender/sexuality, perhaps there is more to be learned by erasing SE from schooling and developing pedagogical resources/spaces elsewhere.

Author