Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Impact of Algebraic Knowledge for Teaching on Student Learning: A Preliminary Analysis

Sat, April 9, 4:05 to 5:35pm, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Two, Marquis Salon 15

Abstract

Objective

The objective of this research is to understand how the quality of teaching affects student mathematics learning, controlling for such confounding factors as individual student characteristics, classroom characteristics, teacher differentials, and school characteristics.

Perspective

Significant advances have been made in research on cognition and effective teaching that contribute to a better understanding of learning and development (Resnick, 1989) and what improves children’s learning (Reynolds, 1989). For instance, teachers interweaving worked examples with practice problems, connecting concrete and abstract representations, and asking deep questions to elicit thoughtful explanations are recommended to improve student learning (Pashler, et al., 2007). Research shows that children from economically disadvantaged circumstances can succeed (Magnuson and Waldfofel, 2005).

Data sources

The underlying model of this quantitative study is that a student’s learning is a function of the teacher’s ability to present the material. Data were collected from almost 250 students attending four schools who were enrolled in eight classes (grades 1 through 4) in a large urban setting. Four data sources were integrated into a single data set: Pre/Post attitude and behavior survey data, Pre/Post test results focused on the material being taught, Videos of the eight teachers presenting four inverse relations materials (a total of 32 lessons), and school data from the US DoE/NCES Common Core of Data. The videos were scored as to how well the lessons were taught in terms of using worked examples, representations, and deep questions based on a rubric adapted from Ding and Carlson (2013). Two individuals scored the videos independently to assess reliability. Data analysis included ANOVA, differences of means, Chi Square, and regression.

Sample Characteristics

The student participants were diverse. On a percentage basis, few were LEP or disabled. The single largest racial category was white and there were more males than females. See Table 7 for specifics.

Results

Mean scores for each teacher’s four videos ranged from 6.5 points to 11.5 points (out of 12 points). In estimating a value added regression analysis model, with the student’s post test scores as the dependent variable, the R Square was .495. Holding constant the students’ presenting knowledge as captured in the pretest score, effective teaching, as captured in the video score, was statistically significant and added .262 to the student’s post test score for every one point increase in the video score (see Table 8).

Significance

The changing educational demands have placed increased emphasis on promoting early learning for children. This growing demand for higher achievement levels means even greater harm for those who fall short of achieving these high levels. Children from poor neighborhoods, children who are LEP, and those who have special needs, are especially at risk of failing. This study will help to improve instruction in order to significantly affect these children’s chances of succeeding.

Authors