Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Socioeconomic Status: A Determinant of Perceptions and Responses to Bullying

Mon, April 11, 7:45 to 9:15am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 160

Abstract

Objective:
This paper suggests the variance of behavioral manifestations of bullying across race, class, gender, and cultural has not been adequately addressed, and therefore compares urban and suburban school environments with embedded socioeconomic differences. Further, this paper asserts since it is the teacher and administrator who report and respond to bullying incidences, the data regarding the details of violence in the classroom can be skewed due to the subjective nature of identification of problematic behaviors. In order to create an improved method of combating these negative behaviors, the author suggests bullying definitions must be realigned to target differences in student culture relating to socioeconomic status. Therefore, the independent variable represented in this study was income as a predicting factor of bullying behaviors and the perceptions and responses of administrators and teachers are presented as the dependent variable.

Modes of Inquiry:
Historically, bullying behaviors were addressed on a situational basis focusing on only perpetrator and victim. Recently, more effective strategies to combat bullying have been designed and implemented with a focus on whole-school approaches (Junoven, 2005; Whitted & Dupper, 2005; Reid et al., 2004). Although the whole-school bullying prevention program has been tested in suburban districts, no studies have examined the efficacy of the program in low-income schools (Hong, 2007). Therefore, data were analyzed within a sociocultural framework, employing theories of social reconstructivism. The resilience research presented here attempts to disrupt hegemonic ideology and deficit model thinking.

Data Sources:
Participants included three administrators and three certified teachers from three districts (see Table 4.1). Study Group A consisted of three administrators and three teachers serving school populations consisting of a majority of students with a median household income of $40,000.00 in 2010. Study Group B consisted of three administrators and three teachers; however, they served school populations with a majority of students residing in households with a median income of less than $22,350.00.

Using a case-study design (Yin, 2009), data collections sources include observations, archival data, open-ended written survey questions and interviews. All teacher meetings were audio-taped and transcribed. Coded using two methods: (1) factors involving race, class, or gender issues as they pertained to bullying behaviors and (2) open-code scheme which indicated changing perspectives.

Findings:
Coded data revealed discrepancies between perceptions and intervention strategies used by teachers implementing anti-bullying regulations among students in a poverty setting and students in upper SES classrooms. Teachers responded with parental contact in upper SES classrooms, finding that this is the number one rated solution, while schools in impoverished environments find the contributing factors that include mental health issues, single parent households, and high levels of violence within the community, as major contributing factors to the pervasiveness of classroom bullying.

Scholarly Significance:
Crothers, Kolbert, & Barker (2006) determined that students ‘sometimes’ or ‘almost always’ found anti-bullying strategies helpful. Teachers with the best classroom management techniques were ranked highly by students in regards to lessening anxiety. Results determined that students desired teacher intervention in attempting to solve bullying problems (Crothers, Kolbert, Barker, 2006).

Author