Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Close Look at Interschool Collaboration in Learning Partners: Three Case Studies

Mon, April 11, 4:30 to 6:00pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level Two, Room 209 B

Abstract

Objectives
This paper presents findings from case study research of schools’ experiences in the New York City Department of Education Learning Partners Program (LPP). The program creates triads of schools by matching one school with promising practices in a learning focus area (LFA) with two schools interested in strengthening their practices in that area. We describe schools’ processes as they engaged in LPP and we explore the conditions necessary for collaborative learning to produce school change.

Perspective
Like other forms of collaborative learning, LPP departs from the “best practice” approach to a more customized method where educators engage in cycles of inquiry across schools to determine what practices to adapt. However, extant research suggests that such collaboration may not be impactful without certain conditions in place, including strong and distributed leadership, shared objectives, defined processes, and an open and trusting community (Atkinson, Springate, Johnson, & Halsey, 2007; Gallimore, Ermeling, & Saunders, 2009; Talbert, 2011; Tschannen-Moran, 2014). This study draws on the teacher collaboration literature to identify the processes and conditions in LPP schools that contributed to the implementation of new practices and school improvement plans.

Methods
We observed the interschool visits of six triads of schools during the first half of the 2014-2015 school year. The eighteen schools represented K-12 grade levels, boroughs across New York City, different LFAs, and varying student populations. After initial observations, we narrowed our sample to three triads that had developed plans to implement new practices. Our case study research of these triads involved further observations, interviews, and artifact analysis (Yin, 2014). In total we observed forty-three visits, thirteen individual school events, thirteen training sessions; and we interviewed twenty-three participants. All interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. Observation notes and transcriptions were coded for evidence of the stages of the learning process and themes that persisted across stages.

Results
Key stages and conditions of the collaborative learning process emerged as crucial for the implementation of new practices through LPP. All schools in the study built relationships, self-assessed, researched practices, adapted and refined those practices, and disseminated them to their greater school communities. Beyond the temporal stages, triads also established conditions that supported LPP work, particularly through the formation of trust, which allowed schools to be transparent about their challenges. Schools also took a coherent approach, where they aligned the work of LPP to school goals and structures. Finally, in order to foster engagement with the work as well as to disseminate practices, schools distributed leadership across the triad and within each school’s individual LPP team.

Significance
The experiences of the three case study triads confirms extant literature about the factors necessary for successful collaboration in schools and extends this literature to work between schools. Further, our study articulates the interschool collaborative processes that can foster professional learning tailored to the particular needs of diverse schools.

Authors