Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In this paper, I compare how two learning environments -- a formal middle school setting and an informal online community of game designers -- structure ideal forms of success using digital technology. Specifically, I examine how each learning space differently facilitates learner identities as innovators and makers. Both cases illustrate provide strong examples of settings where participants are encouraged to creatively engage in digital production (Warschauer & Matuchniak, 2010). But, each setting constructs digital production activities with different parameters, most notably on the relationship between the production process and the participant’s identity as an innovator and maker (Willis, 1977).
Using an ethnographic case study approach over one year, this study draws on interview- and observation-based data collected in each learning setting (Ito et al., 2010). The middle school, Heathcliff Academy (all names are pseudonyms), is a technology-rich private school in Southern California serving mostly White and wealthy youth. The school places an emphasis on digital production as part of its curriculum. I interviewed 18 teachers (86% of the teacher population), and observed their classrooms on rotation for one year to understand the perceived value and uses of digital technology for learning. During the final semester, I selected one ideal type classroom that best fit themes from observation and interviewed half of the students (12) to ascertain their identificational relationship to digital production. The informal learning environment, Sackboy Planet, is an online community for youth with interests in LittleBigPlanet 2, a side-scrolling video game that allows users to not only play the game but also create new games for others to play. I observed communications across the community’s online messages boards to document typical activities around video game design and sharing, and then interviewed 24 youth participants from the community to assess learner identities as they related to digital making.
Comparative analysis of observations in each learning environment demonstrates that while both settings facilitate digital production they differently construct its value. For example, teachers at Heathcliff Academy imagine digital production to be valuable for their students as they strive to become the next Steve Jobs in a startup-saturated labor market. Interviews with students reveal that students come to identify with digital making primarily as it relates to future success in institutional settings, like schools or in their future in the labor market. On Sackboy Planet, however, the perceived goals of digital production were different. In this setting, youth strove to create technologically sophisticated video game levels in order to gain recognition not within institutions, like schools or for jobs, but among their peers. Both Heathcliff Academy and Sackboy Planet thus construct participants as innovators and makers, but they do so in different ways and thus enable learner identities. Heathcliff Academy students come to imagine their digital making primarily as it relates to institutional success, whereas Sackboy Planet youth perceive such activities as a means to facilitate a collective purpose around play and shared learning experience.