Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper uses discourse analytic techniques to inquire into the stances toward learning taken by young people and parents in two distinct informal learning environments: an online platform to share creative writing and a Lego-sponsored exhibit at a Children’s Museum. Combining ethnographic observations and in-depth interviews, this inquiry explores how participants understood learning and schooling and how they positioned their identity vis-à-vis learning and schooling.
The two learning contexts profiled here vary in terms of structural features, learner populations, and involvement of digital publics. The first studied context is a mobile creative writing app called Wattpad, especially popular with adolescent girls. The second is a museum exhibit sponsored by the Lego Corporation aimed at educating elementary school-aged children on building mechanics. Because the contexts of study are distinct, they afford a fruitful comparison of the environments and the identity stances made available in those environments. Interviews with 12 youth participants in each context, their parents, and a multimodal examination of their “works” (creative writing pieces and construction sets, respectively) form the backbone of this analysis of learning identity formation. Thematic and axial coding techniques (Saldaña, 2009) are enrolled to compare the two learning environments and the affordances and constraints they entail for identity building.
Designed environments -- whether physical or digital -- invoke sensibilities, scripts, and social actions, but humans acting within them do the important interpretive work of figuring out the context, what actions belong within it, and, identity “stances” (Gee, 2005). Drawing from critical literacy studies (Luke & Carrington, 2002), I consider how learning environments structure learning stances, dispositions, and positions. Laying out different perspectives on identity as an analytic lens in education research, Gee (2001) posits a tension between the institutional identity perspective and the affinity identity perspective. Institutional identities are imparted onto people by institutions (e.g., school) while affinity identities map onto identity stances based on shared interests (Gee, 2005). This contrast is explored in how and when participants narrate their interest driven activity as helpful for education, schooling, learning, or development. Processes of identification are interrogated within the contours of the particular learning context and the social location of each participant. For instance, some creative writers were able to map their practices onto those of schooling while others call it “not writing” writing distinguishing from school. In parallel, some parents of Lego fans translated play into developmental benefits, drawing on discourses borrowed from pop psychology while others located these practices outside of learning and development. Preliminary analyses show that notions of class and scripts of status mediated the intersection of affinity and institutional discourses.
Broadly, this study considers the way that youth negotiate narratives of identity not of their own making and the way that youth construct their own narratives of the self within power-laden overlapping networks of adult and peer group relations. Understanding how young people and their parents see themselves as “learners” and how such identities are afforded in digitally-mediated spaces has the potential to contribute to the conversation around learning across contexts.