Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This presentation describes an ongoing PAR dissertation, which explores gendered and racialized illegality discourses in varied institutional contexts from the unique perspectives of Latina young women who work as undocumented activists in an immigrant youth organization. I have collaborated with these youth and others for the past five years in a parallel PAR project involving schoolteachers on undocumented issues.
In the 1950’s, social psychologist Kurt Lewin described the limitations of traditional social science research methods for addressing complex human and social problems, and later in the 1970’s alternative research approaches emerged in the so-called Third World nations, such as the co-inquiry, participatory methods for social change developed by the Brazilian educator Paulo Freire among adult populations. These grass roots undertones have been taken over by socially marginalized young people across the globe and community action research scholars, such as social psychologist Michelle Fine, configuring what is commonly known as youth-PAR. All in all, these revolutionary research methods have grounded the philosophical theorizing of participatory action research (PAR) in varied disciplines, including social movements.
As a self-identified immigrant Latina and doctoral student, I came to the field of participatory action research as a community organizer moved by feminist interdisciplinary inquietudes. Throughout the years, I have collaborated in long-term PAR projects with youth and women, among others using theater and photovoice methodologies in both Guatemala and the United States. I am continuously learning and unlearning how the power dynamics involved in these participatory processes are deeply challenging. Some of these concerns leading PAR-related dissertations have to do with life in graduate school. Power issues must be addressed not just by the protagonists leading the research, but also by the institutions that condition how the participatory research is conducted. Feminist scholar and community organizer, Andrea Dyrness (2008) underlines how multiple transformations can be achieved by “highlighting the need for a research process that supports womanist ways of being, based on wholeness and confianza,” which constitute the heart of deeply committed and rigorous PAR.
Aligning with this workshop’s objectives, this presentation grapples with the strengths and challenges of doing youth-PAR work focusing primarily on the following three interrelated themes: data collection/analysis, institutional demands/IRB, and multiple, sometimes conflicting positionalities. My dissertation is broadly configured as an institutional ethnographic case study that combines ethnographic observations with rich interview data. Delgado Bernal’s (1998) analytical concept of “cultural intuition” is used to privilege Latina youth’s viewpoints of illegality, but this attempt is not an easy endeavour. Because of my focus on Latina youth who are undocumented navigating institutional contexts, there are multiple ethical concerns that must be addressed. For instance, the IRB priorities lie in securing confidentiality, whereas issues pertaining to power imbalances between institutions and co-researchers are often overlooked. In addition, my positionality as a researcher and an organizer with this immigrant youth organization fits the duality of asset and liability; hence raising deep epistemological concerns.