Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Indicators of Quality Technology-Enhanced Teaching and Learning

Tue, April 12, 8:15 to 9:45am, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 154 A

Abstract

In this paper we put forward a conceptualization framework for the categorization, development and selection of indicators for quality Technology-Enhanced Learning and Teaching (TEL&T) that is the outcome of discussions of Thematic Working Group 7. The theme of this working group—indicators of quality TEL&T—was stimulated by the need for a set of indicators to be included as an integral part of the indicators that will be needed for monitoring the achievement of the post-2015 Educational Agenda (Education 2030) that is being formulated as a global commitment led by the United Nations and its subordinate organizations (World Education Forum, 2015).
The primary focus of the indicators, as recommended by the UN Statistical Commission and the World Education Forum Technical Advisory Group, should be on learning outcome indicators, but selected input and process indicators should also be included in order to understand and improve the link between policy, policy implementation, outputs and outcomes.

Technology-enhanced learning and teaching (or e-Learning) has become an increasingly important agenda item for education policy makers, school leaders and teachers worldwide. Many countries have launched policy documents on integrating ICT into learning and teaching in the school curriculum since the 1990s. The implementation of these ICT in education masterplans/strategies requires significant investment in hardware and network infrastructure as well as digital learning resources, but also in building requisite human resources capacity. More importantly, research has shown that technology use would only bring about the achievement of “21st century skills” (i.e. the ability to use technology appropriately for communication; collaboration; problem-solving; information access, evaluation and creation) if it is accompanied by innovations in pedagogy and assessment that shift the classroom interactions from teacher-centred instruction to student-centred, inquiry-oriented learning.

Studies in many countries have shown that changes of multilevel actors through their participation and interactions within and across different levels of the education ecosystem are necessary for sustainability, scalability and impact of ICT-enabled learning innovations at the system level (Law, Kampylis and Punie, 2015). Any change observed in any actor can be considered as learning outcomes (e.g. changes in assessment practices in a school is a learning outcome at the school level). The proposed TEL&T indicators framework has a matrix structure, with the levels of the actors as one axes. At each level there are four types of indicators: conditions for learning, learning interactions, e-Learning use and learning outcomes. Any indicator involved in a study on TEL&T can be located within this matrix. This framework makes evident that the learning outcomes at a higher level would serve as the conditions for learning at a lower level in the education ecosystem. This framework can be used to structure a clearinghouse for quality TEL&T indicators and associated analytical tools and visualization applications, thereby serving as an important statistical infrastructure (national and/or international). This will allow meaningful comparison and aggregation of data and complex multilevel analysis, and will support data sharing and research collaboration.

Authors