Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Visiting Washington, D.C.
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Recent neoliberal educational and evaluation policies have intensified a focus on school leadership, learning results, and national curriculum standards. The increased focus on leadership is combined with a renewed relation between policy as curriculum-making, leadership as enacted practice, and evaluation as a steering vehicle. The replacing of one bureaucracy with another as well as the inclusion of the transnational level has turned our attention towards understanding educational leadership as a multi-level project. We can observe a redefinition of how power and influence is distributed anew between and within each of these levels.
In this paper, we present a framework for curriculum work-leadership that keeps levels of the system together, theoretically, building upon strengths and recognizing limitations of policy studies, educational leadership studies, curriculum theory / didaktik, modern general education theory / philosophy, and discursive institutionalism. In constructing our framework, we asked two questions, one involving the nature of influence between leaders and those being influenced, and the other concerning relations among education politics, economy and culture. In modern thought, education is often viewed as invitation or provocation to self-reflection and autonomy. Using this argument, leadership is understood as a recognizing invitation or provocation, or a disturbance concerning the Other’s relation to himself/herself, the world and others. We find three concepts particularly relevant: 1) recognition, 2) summoning to self-activity and 3) Bildsamkeit (Benner, 1991, Author, 2002).
The second question concerns how a theory explains the relation between education and politics, economy and culture, respectively, as non-hierarchical. Here education is seen in a non-hierarchical relation to politics, culture and economy. Education is not solely placed either “outside” or “inside” the society and is, thus, not either super or subordinated with respect to society but attempts to mediate between the two. It should be observed that a non-hierarchical understanding accepts that hegemonic political interests influence education, but recognises that if educational leadership were to be reduced in the service of some political ideology, it would be in conflict with democratic principles. In this non-hierarchical conceptualization, educational institutions are given relative independence with respect to societal and other interests. It is this space that both allows for and requires reflective among leaders and others in each level of the system. Discursive institutionalism (Schmidt, 2008) offers a complementary approach to understanding how educational policies, ideas and values (curriculum) relate to administrative processes on different levels. As we see it, discursive institutionalism itself presupposes a non-hierarchical understanding of societal forms of practice.
Our intent in developing this framework is to keep two levels of education together: (a) the cultural societal level and (b) the institutional-interactional level. Thus, we move beyond the limitations of extant theory (i.e. the lack of attention to the interplay between societal and micro, social interactional levels; the normative nature of dominant theories and their regulatory and transformational aims; underlying epistemologies and ontologies; limited language to talk about various systems). In our framework, then, curriculum theory, leadership/institutional studies (structure) and policy (ideas) now complete each other conceptually.