Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Neoliberalism and the Privatization of Urban Schools in India

Mon, April 16, 12:25 to 1:55pm, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Second Floor, Nassau Room West

Abstract

Purpose. The rise of neoliberalism in India has exacerbated poverty in urban communities where most public institutions are being privatized, including public schools. This paper discusses the politics of markets and privatization in India and how such policies have perpetuated the marginalization of urban children despite existing government policies to ensure universal and free education to all children. The lack of access to quality public education makes it inevitable for urban families to be steered toward private schools, which are fast-growing. This paper unpacks the assumptions that quality education takes place in these low-fee private schools. It describes the consequences of these schools, showing how they undercut the educational opportunities of the urban poor, especially the children of urban communities who are systematically denied access to education.

Theoretical framework. India’s Right to Education Act of 2009 was a landmark decision and signaled a promise to invest in India’s children regardless of race, class, caste, or gender. However, with the rise of neoliberalism, public schools were not financially supported, rather parents were encouraged to send their children to what is known as low-fee private schools (Lewin, 2017). Proponents of privatization argue that it creates conditions for competition, with the assumption that if parents engaged in market mechanisms in education, their children will be awarded better opportunities (Chubb & Moe, 1999). However, Apple, 2006; Whitty, Power; & Halpin, 1998 have shown that privatization is a neoliberal agenda in education which reproduces educational inequalities.

Methods and Data Sources. This research is based on extensive review of literature on issues of poverty and privatization in India. The study uses data from a recent study by the Developmental Leadership Program on the societal attitudes toward poverty in India (Dasandi, 2015), which reconfirmed the attitudes toward poverty. It has also reviewed literature and research on privatization, neoliberalism, and markets in education, not just in India, but in other countries as well.

Results. As a case study, this research found that India represents the social and cultural hotbed of contradictory tensions in regard to its education system. Despite government explicit policies to support education, this has turned out not to be the case. Instead, this study found that with increasing privatization of education, education has become a form of entitlement that caters to an upwardly mobile sector of the society, while children of low-income families are denied such opportunities. The right to universal education remains an unfulfilled goal as neoliberal policies fail to address the exploitative nature of superficial low-fee private schools.

Scholarly Significance. This paper brings to our attention the retrogressive market oriented reforms in education in India. It brings an awareness of the plight of the majority of the urban poor in India who have been turned into outcasts, largely by poverty, which is perpetuated by neoliberal policies. More specific, this research shows that although low-fee private schools are on the rise in India, they fare no better than their government counterparts in educating India’s poor children.

Author