Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Logic of the Exception and Instrumental Violence: School Shootings Revisited

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 10:15am, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Second Floor, Gramercy Room East

Abstract

This paper addresses a recurring claim following school shootings: The cultural, political, and educational milieus must be absolved from any direct or indirect responsibility. Citing specific examples, I show how school shootings are often considered anomalous acts or, when common factors are identified, as perpetrated by isolated mentally ill individuals. Shooters are often “ex-cepted,” cast out as disconnected human aberrations. I argue that this assertion of exceptionality distorts the connections between shooters and their settings, implying a definitive separation between normal and exceptional, between what is expected in the course of human events and what is excepted as sociohistorical or psychological aberrations. Suggesting shooters reveals much about the ethos of a community, society, or nation, I suggest a response to school shootings that deposes the logic of exceptionality.
The assertion of disconnection between place and shooter often yields explicit and implicit rhetorical questions: How could someone so violent “belong” to this peaceful, ordinary community? How could something so violent occur in a place such as this? This stark contrast between perpetrator and place often frames the outrage, leading to media spectacles of stark black and white contrasts, as the “unthinkable” stands out in sharp relief from the ordinary.
To show these prevailing binaries and what they conceal, I draw on the writings of Walter Benjamin (1921,1940) on the nexus between violence and law, and on Giorgio Agamben’s (1998, 2002, 2005) extensions of Benjamin’s notions of the “sovereign decision” and the “state of exception.” I show how responses to school shootings — from gun enthusiasts and the gun lobby, in particular — tend both to appropriate and, paradoxically, to dismiss certain kinds of violence. In doing so, they imply a specific vision of the self: Individuals are sovereign, able to exert power over bodily life, and able to remove themselves from community norms, invoking the “sovereign exception” (Agamben, 1998, pp. 28, 34, 66).
I then suggest how Benjamin’s critique of instrumental violence (1921) can inform new efforts to challenge binaries of good and evil, urban and suburban, individual and community, justice and law, normal and exceptional, that confound our deliberations and long-term responses to shootings. Examining school shootings from the standpoint of instrumental violence, I argue that school shootings emerge in conceptual, sociocultural, and political contexts in which governmental, military, and police violence are deemed justifiable. This kind of instrumental justification for state violence, then, extends to juridical, social, psychological, and physical violence throughout our society. In the name of the law (the Second Amendment), the gun lobby invokes the purportedly unfettered right to bear arms. In the name of a “stand your ground” law, a shooter claims the right to kill. In the name of justice and honor, a shooter sprays his bullets. These examples are but extensions of instrumental justifications for state-sponsored violence. I seek, then, to open a field for human action and educational response that might free us from instrumental justifications of violence and from the logic of the exception.

Author