Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Aftermath of School Shootings: A Model for Relational Aesthetic Response, Reconstruction, and Associated Living

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 10:15am, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Second Floor, Gramercy Room East

Abstract

Purpose: This chapter is a pragmatic shift toward research on and development of effective response strategies in the aftermath of school shootings. Our aim is to further discussion about planning and policy development and for the purposeful enactment of relational aesthetic response by teachers and administrators, who must work with violent and disturbing incidents. First, we review an Aesthetic Response model that is based on educational strategies, relational aesthetic response, and associated living practices found through analysis of three identified sites: Columbine High School, Red Lion Junior High School, and Sandy Hook Elementary School. Second, research results are summarized on aesthetic responses to school shootings. Third, we explore potential strategies that address ongoing recovery and policy development for the later aftermath of a school shooting, which are based on national guidelines (NEA, n.d.).
Theoretical framework: Our frameworks are the pragmatic educational thought of John Dewey (1934/2005) and Arts Based Educational Research (ABER) (Baron & Eisner, 1997). We contribute to education theory and practice through discussion on how Deweyan thought and ABER can assist the education community to make meaning of violent events.
This exploratory and theoretical research project utilizes ABER methodology. Three sites were selected that experienced shooting events and had a public display of aesthetic response via multiple media sites. Our methods were a dialogic process with emergent, collaborative, and ongoing meaning making (Paulus, Woodside, and Ziegler, 2008). Analysis of themes and artful representation took place during review of data sources. A non-exhaustive review of the literature was conducted pertaining to the potential application of the findings to the national response guidelines (NEA, n.d.).
Data sources for research analysis and the development of the Aesthetic Response model were the digital sites and media descriptions of artful works and expressive responses. Researcher journal, graphs, and observation notes were kept throughout the process of data analysis and interpretation.
Research results are three-fold. First, common themes of evolving expression and relational identity were found in aesthetic responses across art forms, media, and building design. Second, researchers identified an Aesthetic Response model, a 7-step process of responsive artful conduct and creative behavior. Findings suggest engagement in responsive aesthetic projects may ameliorate the effects of school shootings. There is potential for beneficial reclamation, restoration, and re-presentation of the traumatic experience through the doubled reconstruction of communal spaces and of relational identity. Third, research findings can be utilized for teacher and administrator training and for the development of effective response strategies in the later aftermath of and recovery from a shooting incident.
Significance: First, school shootings continue (Everytown, 2016) and there is a need for effective response and recovery in the later aftermath. Second, the Aesthetic Response model provides a means to think through the interaction between continual social reconstruction, as well as adjustment for individuals, communities, and spaces of associated living. Third, this research addresses a gap in the literature regarding the development and application of effective educational response strategies in the later aftermath of a shooting incident.

Authors