Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teaching to Support Productive Struggle: Exploring Tensions Between Positive Teacher-Student Relationships and Mathematical Relationships

Mon, April 16, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Seventh Floor, Room 7.01

Abstract

Framework & Objectives: Positive teacher-student relationships (TSR) are essential for quality learning. When strong, TSRs promote higher academic achievement and behavioral adjustment (Hamre & Pianta, 2005). They are associated with pleasant peer relationships (Hughes & Kwok, 2006), better engagement in the classroom (Furrer & Skinner, 2003) and higher overall achievement (Crosnoe, Johnson & Elder, 2004), and therefore are highly encouraged.
Boynton and Boynton (2005) suggest five strategies for promoting such relationships: (i) communicating positive expectations, (ii) correcting students in a constructive way, (iii) developing classroom pride, (iv) demonstrating caring, and (iv) preventing your own frustration and stress. However, some of these approaches may conflict with highly effective practices in mathematics education (see NCTM, 2000). Therefore, enacting these practices in the math classroom may not support the kind of TSRs critical for developing strong mathematical thinkers (hereafter referred to as mathematically productive relationships -MPRs). For example, Boynton and Boynton suggest communicating positive expectations by calling on students equitably. However, two essential practices for supporting productive mathematical learning is being selective about the student responses showcased for discussion and to sequence these tasks in ways that extend students’ thinking (Stein & Smith, 2011). Such high-quality practices geared toward advancing student thinking will be referred to as mathematical practices.
In this study we first examine the degree of alignment between Boynton and Boynton’s suggested actions and mathematical practices; then, we describe the kinds of TSRs elementary teachers believe supported mathematical practices. Finally, we examine which practices related to building TSRs align with high-quality mathematics instruction.
Method & Data: The seven teachers completed five hour-long interviews which were transcribed and analysed. Teachers’ lesson videos were analyzed using the Mathematical Quality of Instruction (MQI) instrument (http://isites.harvard.edu/icb/icb.do?keyword=mqi_training&tabgroupid=icb.tabgroup120173) to determine the quality of their instruction. Videos that showcased a range of instruction were identified, then used to provide descriptions of the teachers’ practices which were compared to mathematical and Boynton and Boynton’s practices. Teachers’ descriptions of their beliefs about MPRs were compared with the observed teachers’ practices.
Results: Analyses showed that all the teachers’ beliefs about actions that contributed to MPRs aligned with mathematical practices. However, consistent with existing research, what teachers believed did not always align with their actions. For example, Anderson talked about the importance of struggle and making mistakes; yet he consistently scored low on the MQI and predominant used a teacher-centered approach to teaching. In contrast, Winona’s teaching consistently displayed mathematical practices, had high scores on the MQI showing a connection between mathematical practices and high-quality instruction. Both teachers’ practices showed some elements of Boynton and Boynton’s actions.
Significance: Although Boynton and Boynton’s suggestions for building positive teacher-student relationships support equity, trust-building and rapport, these strategies may not be sufficient for building MPRs. Mathematics teachers must be able to meaningfully support students as they take risks, engage in challenging problem-solving and experience productive struggle. As such, it is important that mathematics teacher educators and professional developers support teachers to determine the integration of actions that creates MPRs and optimizes mathematics learning.

Authors