Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Path of Conocimiento for Young Brown Girls: Using Counterspaces to Explore Gender Consciousness

Tue, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Fourth Floor, Lincoln Suite

Abstract

This study focused on the processes by which elementary aged Brown girls made sense of their multiple, intersectional identities, through the lens of Anzaldúa’s (2002) path of conocimiento. Specifically, this research highlights how applying an Anzaldúan lens to the experiences of young Latinas can illuminate the various contradictions they embody as they navigate multiple, marginalized identities tied to income, race, immigration status, age, and gender. Critical Race Counterspaces (Morales, 2017) provided a needed platform for this research that allowed for a centering of contradiction, tension, and critical dialogue. In integrating ethnic studies based pedagogical approaches within the counterspace created as a part of this research, participants could explore parts of their identities that traditional schooling practices stifle or neglect. This research then, examines how counterspaces provided an entryway for young Brown girls to make sense of their conocimientos within a context that viewed these conocimientos as valuable and as a form of resiliency.
Gloria Anzaldúa’s conceptualization of her theory of the borderlands largely drives this study, in conjunction with Critical Race Theory. In particular, I focus on Anzaldúa’s understanding of an ongoing process of consciousness, articulated by her as a path of conocimiento. Critical Race Theory within the field of education, provides an understanding of how racism and other forms of subordination persist despite moments of social progress. Counterspaces are one way in which communities of color actively resist oppression.
Data was collected for this study during the 2014-2015 academic year. Using qualitative and ethnographic methods, the data consists of pláticas (Fierros & Delgado Bernal, 2016), field notes and observations, and focus groups with eight 5th grade Latinas.
Viewing the counterspace that we collectively developed as “not like schooling” the young Latinas in this study felt more comfortable in expressing themselves, sharing the contradictions they felt in both wanting and not wanting attention from their male counterparts. These girls lived in a neighborhood that they knew was coded as largely Brown, “ghetto”, and poor, and could distinguish the difference between where they lived and where their predominantly white teachers lived. Thus, though their surrounding environment made salient their race, class, and gender, their everyday schooling experiences centered their gender identity, given that their school was predominantly Latinx. These young Brown girls understood the coded language of patriarchy through their various interactions with the boys at their school, who they recognized as negotiating their own embodiment of masculinity.
In highlighting how young Brown girls make sense of themselves within a societal context that devalues their multiple identities, there is room for educators to better understand how ethnic studies and culturally responsive and asset based approaches, can provide a space for young girls of color to navigate their ongoing consciousness. Additionally, this research argues that we need more purposeful engagement of Chicana feminist frameworks within educational literature as a means of challenging the traditional approaches to education that we have long known to be ineffective for historically marginalized students.

Author