Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

At the Margins of Canada: Aboriginal Families' School Choice in a Settler-Colonial City

Fri, April 13, 4:05 to 5:35pm, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Fourth Floor, Holland Suite

Abstract

Does school choice provide ‘better’ education for all families, especially those who have been historically marginalized? While more and more studies demonstrate that school choice is not a panacea to solve all the problems of education, especially for disadvantaged families in affluent societies, these studies also inform us that studying the school choice practices and patterns of marginalized groups needs to be socially and spatially contextualized (Gulson, 2011; Lipman, 2011; Yoon & Lubienski, 2017). The objective of this presentation is thus to shed light on the school choice practices and patterns of a historically marginalized group of aboriginal families, arguably one of the most under-researched groups in school choice studies, in a particular context of a settler-colonial city in Canada. The aim is to understand the possibilities and limits of school choice from the position of aboriginal families who have endured the trauma of colonialism and racism at the margins of Canada. This presentation focuses on the lived meanings and spatial patterns of school choice among aboriginal mothers and their children (K-12) in Vancouver.
To understand the experiences of school choice from the perspectives of aboriginal families, while also focusing on the centrality of the colonial relationships and structures that entrap aboriginal families’ life at the margins of the colonial society, this study draws on settler-colonial theory and critical theories of capital and space (Bourdieu, 1999; Soja, 1996; Wolfe, 2006). These theories are drawn together to highlight how aboriginal families continue to face and navigate unequal power relations, exclusion, elimination, and dispossession as the structural consequences of colonial conquest.
This study applies a mixed-method research design, namely, critical Geographic Information Systems, in order to understand aboriginal families’ choice practices through their lived experiences, and examines their choice patterns through their mobility in the city. The study analyzes interviews with eight aboriginal family members, collected as part of a larger study of 40 marginalized urban family members in Vancouver in 2015. The qualitative data are triangulated with a geo-spatial analysis of the school choice of approximately 700 aboriginal students at the secondary school level (2014-15), using Geographic Information Systems.
Both qualitative and quantitative data indicate that aboriginal families take part in school choice in order to ensure school success and future economic mobility, resonating with other studies of racially marginalized families’ school choice (Cooper, 2007; Yoon & Lubienski, 2017). However, they face unique challenges of painful and traumatic experiences of colonialism and racism when considering school options in a settler-colonial city that is still racially divided. These divisions limit school choice options and that school choice participation is concentrated in a particular school in one part of the city. This study also finds that aboriginal students are grossly underrepresented in selective choice programs in the public school system.
Overall, this study elucidates that neoliberal policy of school choice is inadequate to meet the needs of aboriginal families, and indeed, their choices are highly constrained by racialized space at the margins of the settler-colonial city.
 

Authors