Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Charter and Public School Comparisons Across Neighborhoods in an Urban Context

Mon, April 16, 4:05 to 5:35pm, Crown Plaza Times Square, Floor: Fifth Floor, Room 501/502

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to provide an in-depth analysis of St. Louis City neighborhoods and public and charter schools serving this urban city. The research task is to compare academic performance of charter and public schools in urban neighborhoods with varying degrees of concentrated disadvantage to determine if charter schools result in higher performance. Comparison of charter and public school performance has shown large variation in results across 27 states (CREDO, 2013). How much of this variation is associated with different neighborhood contexts?
Why are neighborhood contexts important for schools? Schools are one of the key components of a community’s social infrastructure and a significant catalyst in enhancing collective efficacy of neighborhood residents to foster mutual trust and shared willingness to intervene for the common good (Sampson, Raudenbush, and Earls, 1997; Sampson, 2012b). Local schools cannot be the only organizations supporting the social structure of a community, but significant collective efficacy and social capital can be enhanced by the networks and relationships established in schools. If the disparity becomes too great between neighborhood schools within the community, then collective efficacy of the community as a whole suffers as concentrated disadvantage becomes more localized (Sampson, 2012a).
Data are from 17 St. Louis City charter elementary and 36 public schools dispersed widely throughout the city. A nearest neighborhood spatial analysis shows lack of significant clustering which provides an opportunity to compare charter-public school performance within and across a variety of urban neighborhoods. Academic data are from MO Dept. of Elementary and Secondary Education (2015) and census tract data are from the American Community Survey.
For charter and public schools, comparisons are made for the percentage of students who scored proficient/advanced in language arts (LA) and mathematics in third and fifth grades. These comparisons are done in the context of a variety of variables typically associated with concentrated disadvantage such as poverty, vacant building percentage, unemployment, racial diversity, and single female household. The goal is to examine neighborhoods where factors of concentrated disadvantage vary and compare the academic performance of students attending charter and public schools. The methods include spatial mapping of variables associated with concentrated disadvantage and the location and performance of schools within these areas. Charter-public school mean comparisons for LA and math proficiency are made within neighborhood contexts.
Results show that charter-public school percent proficient differ by neighborhood census tracts. Students in charter schools are not uniformly more proficient than those in public schools. For example, charter schools in high poverty tracts (GT 50%) have significantly greater percent proficient in math grades 3 and 5, but no significant charter-public differences in low poverty tracts. Similar analyses are conducted for the other variables listed above.
This study demonstrates that charter-public school student proficiency varies by location in an urban city whose neighborhoods are diverse in people, poverty, and the built environment. Neighborhood and place matter in student performance along with a school’s ability to overcome factors associated with concentrated disadvantage.

Author