Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Subjectivity as a Site of Struggle Against New Public Management

Sat, April 14, 8:15 to 9:45am, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Fourth Floor, Lincoln Suite

Abstract

While insider/practitioner research has traditionally been a vehicle used to explore and change educational practices and structures (Anderson, Herr & Nihlen, 2007; Cochran-Smith & Lytle, 2009) it has rarely interrogated the ways new public management is transforming public education. This despite Ball & Olmedo’s (2013) observation that neoliberalism manifests in the “mundane and everyday practices of institutional life,” the very arena that insider/practitioner research takes as its focus. In this paper we focus on this disconnect between the potential and the practices of practitioner research while also affirming its social justice aims and transformative possibilities toward the public good. We are cognizant that many of the spaces typically generative for practitioner research (inquiry groups, professional learning communities) have been colonized and put in service of examining data toward raising an institution’s standing on standardized measures. But in this paper, we propose to move beyond these kinds of constraints, important though they are, to take up how new professionalism is reworking researcher subjectivities.
The promotion of new professional subjectivities is seen by many as the real threat of new public management (Thomas & Davies, 2002). Citing work by du Gay (1996) Thomas and Davies (2002) argue that NPM is “an identity project,” striking at the heart of academic professionalism, increasing management’s power and reducing professional autonomy. As Ball (2003) observes, current reforms do not simply change what we as educators do, it changes who we are. Recognizing subjectivity as a key site of political struggle within neoliberalism generally, Ball (2015) outlines a “politics of refusal.” He makes the case that neoliberalism is enacted or refused by the individual, “never in an absolutely sense, rather within multiple ‘strategic skirmishes.’ The issue is one of a recognition of and engagement with relations of power” (2015, p. 3).
While more commonly recognizing the identity reworking involved for ourselves as educators, implications for our researcher selves have gone relatively untroubled. But Bauman suggests, “Social science must do its part to trace the opportunities and challenges of the hybrid work of becoming, being, and belonging” (2000, cited in Thomson & Gunter, 2011, p. 27). In this paper we suggest that part of the politics of refusal may involve the recognition of how, in leaving unquestioned the professional boundaries we impose upon our own research, we may collude with the reworking of our subjectivities. We explore the possibilities of practitioner action research in our own sites as a tool to further the politics of refusal that Ball calls for. We first ask what it means for a researcher to “be professional” in this era of new professionalism, coupling this with inquiry into professional and researcher ethics. We then go on to probe how we might conduct “good enough” (Lutrell, 2010) insider/practitioner research that could take up a reworking of ourselves and our work places toward the public good.

Authors