Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Preschool Children's Awareness of When Learning and Physical Events Occurred

Sun, April 15, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Crown Plaza Times Square, Floor: Fourth Floor, Times Square B Room

Abstract

Young children have difficulty recognizing when something happened, especially when it is a learning event, although past research has not directly compared preschool children’s reporting of learning vis-à-vis physical events. Distinguishing between these events relates to the metacognitive skill of source monitoring; it also addresses semantic and episodic memory development. In addition to event type, assessment method also makes a difference, such that preschoolers are more accurate answering temporal distance than temporal location questions. However, past research on assessment method was confounded by question frame, making it premature to draw the conclusion that preschool children understand temporal distance earlier than temporal location. This research was thus conducted to fill a void and address a weakness in extant research.
In two experiments, 55 3- to 5-year-olds participated in two activity sessions, a week apart. In Experiment 1 in the first session, children learned the fictional animal fact of “grambees eat grass” and the made-up body movement of “how to zwib”. Each child also colored a grambee line drawing and posed for a photo while zwibbing. In the second session, children learned “wugs sleep in the sand” and “how to hink”. Each child then colored a wug line drawing and posed for a photo while hinking. In Experiment 2, children experienced the events across the two sessions in the reversed order. Immediately after the second session in both experiments, children were individually asked forced-choice temporal location (e.g., “Which did you learn before today / today, ‘grambees eat grass’ or ‘wugs sleep in the sand’?”) and temporal distance (e.g., “Which did you learn a longer time ago / just learn, ‘grambees eat grass’ or ‘wugs sleep in the sand’?”) questions about when the various events occurred.
In Experiment 1, a 2 (Event Type: learning, physical) X 2 (Assessment Method: location, distance) within-subjects ANOVA revealed a significant interaction between Event Type and Assessment Method, F (1, 18) = 10.83, p = .004, 2 = .376. Simple effects analyses found that temporal distance questions (M = 1.53, SD = .61) better helped young children than temporal location questions (M = 1.00, SD = .82) in recognizing when learning events occurred, F (1, 18) = 4.57, p = .047, 2 = .202. In Experiment 2, a significant main effect of Assessment Method was found: Children were more accurate in recognizing when events occurred when asked temporal distance questions (M = 1.25, SE = .13) than when asked temporal location questions (M = .87, SE = .12), F (1, 25) = 4.66, p = .041, 2 = .157.
Therefore, given that young children recognized when they experienced learning and physical events similarly after one week, their difficulty recognizing new learning is not likely due to the internal nature of learning. Rather, the questions they are asked appear to be a more important factor. Overall then, this line of inquiry increases our understanding of young children’s memory and metacognition development, and carries the potential to help us build an enriched learning experience for children.

Author