Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Struggle for Innovation in Teacher Education: A Case of Collective Creativity

Tue, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, New York Marriott Marquis, Floor: Fourth Floor, Odets

Abstract

Pre-service teacher education has become a site of struggle for both liberal/progressive and critical forms of public education in countries around the world. As a field, the historical dominance of the universities has often drawn critique from across the political spectrum that it is slow to change and resistant to innovation. In this paper, we draw on our research into historical innovations in pre-service teacher education in England between 1965 and 1987. We focus particularly on the internationally significant Oxford Internship Scheme, a research-informed pre-service programme developed and implemented by a partnership between Oxford University, the local education authority in Oxfordshire and local schools, to offer an analysis of its development as an instance of collective creativity over the period 1973 to 1987.
In making this analysis, we draw on two main data sets: first, long recorded interviews and unrecorded conversations with key protagonists from that period; second, an archive of documents collected by some of these key protagonists covering most if not all aspects of the scheme’s development. Data was subjected to two analytic passes: first, a hermeneutic process of narrative inquiry with each of the key protagonists; second, an analysis of the interactions between the multiple oral and textual accounts of change using concepts derived from Cultural Historical Activity Theory (CHAT).
Through the analysis of how this programme emerged over a 14-year period, we show how such an innovation may be seen as a collectively creative response to a ground up feeling of a need to change amongst its principal actors. We also explore the importance of this ‘felt need to change’ in order for innovation to occur. Specifically, we account for the absence of any references to the (contemporary) policy and political environment of the time (1973 – 1987) from the data sets –a policy and political environment with strong similarities to the present day. The paper concludes by considering implications for change in teacher education particularly in the current policy contexts internationally that has seen, variously, governments taking more control from the center and specifying standards but also creating a de-regulated market of diversified teacher education provision.

Authors