Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Pre-Kindergarten and Kindergarten Academic Language Intervention in a Public School District Serving Low-Income English Learners

Mon, April 16, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Fifth Floor, Room 5.08

Abstract

Objectives: The purpose of this paper is to consider how to build teacher knowledge and skills necessary to meet the academic language challenges of young children within a public school district serving predominantly low-income dual language learners. We explored this through a pilot study of an oral language curriculum supplement designed for Spanish-speaking dual language learners (DLL). The Developing Talkers (DT) program is a supplemental curriculum and professional development intervention that could be integrated into any core curriculum.

Framework: Early academic language interventions warrant investigation because deficits in oral language skills are associated with later reading or academic difficulties (NELP, 2008). Over time, oral language skills become increasingly predictive of later reading comprehension, particularly for DLL who often have long-term reading comprehension difficulties despite adequate decoding and fluency skills (e.g., Proctor, Carlo, August, & Snow, 2005; Verhoeven & Van Leeuwe, 2008). Multi-tiered systems of support (MTSS) are designed to prevent later academic difficulties by providing early and additive supports to high-need students. Public schools increasingly use MTSS models. DT is organized using an MTSS framework that includes whole-group/Tier 1 lessons and targeted small-group/Tier 2 lessons for the five lowest performing students within each class. DT teaches over 200 academic vocabulary words and poses 300+ inferential-level questions through 26 read alouds; learning is reinforced with 70+ extension activities.

Methods: The DT program was evaluated using a randomized waitlist-control, posttest only design including 31 intervention and 36 waitlist-control classrooms. The study was conducted in all pre-kindergarten (pre-k) and kindergarten (K) English instruction classrooms within a school district located on the Texas/Mexico border that served mostly DLL from low-income backgrounds.

Data sources: In addition to the district’s existing screening/progress monitoring measures for MTSS, teachers assessed 1,193 students using a researcher-developed vocabulary measure of 30 words taught in the program. Eleven untaught/exposure words were also tested. As a transfer task, teachers submitted pretest and posttest videos of read alouds of a book beyond the DT program. Read alouds were scored for instructional quality. Fidelity of implementation was monitored via multiple videos of DT lessons.

Results: ANCOVA analyses on the district’s screening measure showed no group differences at pretest. As shown in Table 1, pre-k and K students in the intervention group outperformed students in the waitlist-control group on instructed and untaught/exposed words with large effect sizes at pre-k (d=1.29) and K (d=.84). Teachers implemented the DT program with adequate fidelity. However, Table 2 shows that teachers in the DT group did not demonstrate higher quality oral language instruction in a transfer read aloud than waitlist-control teachers. And DT teachers’ classroom management was weaker than waitlist controls (d=-.71).

Significance: Children made large gains in academic vocabulary when an academic language curriculum supplement was used. However, teachers did not generalize use of these high-quality teaching practices in other contexts. We will discuss successes and challenges and present videotaped instruction segments to reflect on lessons learned. We further explore the potential need for an educative curriculum approach to achieve both child and teacher growth in public schools.

Authors