Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Mass School Closures and the Politics of Race, Value, and Disposability in Philadelphia

Sun, April 15, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Park Central Hotel New York, Floor: Mezzanine Level, Manhattan B Room

Abstract

In the past decades, urban school districts across this nation have adopted school closures as a way to cope with the loss of students and funds. Although school closings have received considerable attention in the media as a controversial reform, reconfiguring the educational landscapes of over 70 post-industrial cities like Chicago, Detroit, and New Orleans, in the last decade, few scholars have considered the project of examining closures – their process and their effects – empirically.

Current scholarship on school closures has focused on closures’ effects on academic achievement for transferring students, cost savings for struggling urban districts, and ramifications for social justice as working class Black communities lose their neighborhood schools. We situate ourselves in this latter camp by exploring how the process of closure unfolded across two demographically different neighborhood schools (e.g. one majority Asian; another majority Black) with similar academic performance statistics.

Through an archival excavation of Philadelphia’s rollout of mass closures in 2012 and 2013, we first compare how discourses of race and value informed the politics around these closures at the district level through document analysis of district deliberations as well as dozens of interviews with district officials. We then move to a school-level analysis, drawing on hundreds of interviews and hours of participant observation across our two distinct research sites: Franklin High School, a predominately Black high school that closed in 2013, and Johnson High School, a predominately Asian high school that was on and then removed from the closures list in 2012, prior to the closure of 30 schools between June 2012 and June 2013. In addition to their individual case studies, the authors jointly transcribed and coded over two-dozen community and district meetings’ video recording during the 2012 and 2013 closures. In the aftermath of the school closures process, we used a comparative ethnographic method to compare and contrast the events that occurred at these two schools.

Suturing anthropologies of violence and education to frame the analysis, we explore moments of collision between policy discourses deployed by state and local officials that crafted closures in as inevitable and threatened school communities’ articulations of the racialized implications of the closures. We further localize our analysis to demonstrate how two school communities – one majority Asian and another majority Black – with similar performances and characteristics, met dramatically different fates. Given the lack of transparency in how decisions were made around which schools to close, they ways in which these communities read and responded to the closure threat, offers a window into the ways in which race informed the valuation process across schools. Moving beyond educational studies that have focused on the outcomes of mass school closures like student achievement and cost savings, we argue that a thorough theorization of race, violence, and community value’s relation to school-closure as process could help to explain the ways in which contemporary educational policy reforms are creating new modes of communal disposability in cities’ poorest zip codes.

Authors