Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Participating While Poor in the Public School Closure Process

Sun, April 15, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Park Central Hotel New York, Floor: Mezzanine Level, Manhattan B Room

Abstract

In 2013, Chicago and Philadelphia made U.S. History when they closed-down the most schools in a single year. Across both cities, over 20,000 students were affected, 90% of which were either Black or Latino and low-income. The large number of closures, and its racially targeted nature, raises serious questions about the equitable distribution of public goods by government and the impacts of these decisions on the political beliefs of Americans most directly affected. This paper examines how resource poor groups participate in the policy process and the impacts of their engagement.

Utilizing a qualitative data set on public school closures in Chicago and Philadelphia, I demonstrate how the structure of the closure process eliminates many of the barriers for citizens targeted for closure (e.g., resources) by providing access to school officials through the establishment of community meetings set up for the primary purpose of voicing opinions on the issue and resources such as buses to attend them. The provision of resources, access to officials and spaces to participate allow for long overdue engagement by and between the district and community groups. This increased engagement by the district contributes to the development of citizens’ civic skills, affirms internal efficacy and facilitates collective action.

Yet, these resources are only provided to those affected by closure under oppressive circumstances and at the last minute—to facilitate participation toward a negative policy decision. Furthermore, in both cities three times more schools were closed in 2013 than the year before; totaling nearly ten percent of the public-school system. Thus, despite the collective action and participation of those targeted for closure, the effect of their participation, in terms of real policy change, remains elusive. The findings suggest that when citizens from resource poor backgrounds receive support in the form of collective resources, they can, and do, participate, and from their participation they gain important lessons for future engagement. Yet, the status quo remains unchanged.

Author