Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Do Refugee-Background Youth Mobilize and Language Emotion for Critical Media Literacy?

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 9:45am, Sheraton New York Times Square, Floor: Lower Level, Gramercy Room

Abstract

Purpose and Perspectives
This paper will examine the role of emotion in classroom discussions of place- or culture-informed media among East African refugee-background youth in a multiethnic secondary class. Typical critical media pedagogies intended to position students as agentive interpreters and creators of media texts. However, these same pedagogies can lead to feelings of shame, anger, or resentment when media representations meant for critique relentlessly cast students’ cultures, communities, and bodies in ways that are not culturally authentic and are often demeaning or fear-mongering. We theorize emotion not as a circumstantial state of mind, but as action linked to language and identity, and argue that critical media literacy is deeply related to how students and teachers, as social actors, mobilize emotion to understand, transform and communicate about texts and signs. We also draw from the concept of “proper distance” (Silverstone, 2003, 2007) to consider the ways in which the youth responded to a media artifact during class, considering that we, white female teachers, were facilitating the discussion.

Modes of Inquiry and Data Sources
Our data come from ethnographic, qualitative classroom-based research which explores developing critical media literacy through the production of artifacts shared among peers through social media and face-to-face interactions. This paper will explore a moment when while teaching a high school ESL class involving the sharing of a Somali house on social media. The analysis was based on an audio recordings of classroom discourse as well as post-event reflections of these moments.

Conclusions and Scholarly Significance
Results show the complexity of the discussion, based on not only the media literacy content but also interlocutors; namely, the perceptions the youth had of the teacher. Implications of this work include new considerations of student emotion as a resource that can challenge educators to examine some of the unintended consequences of using culturally charged but authentic materials with refugee-background youth. Implications also point to the way “otherness” (Turner, 2002) takes shape in everyday classroom interactions, as individuals understand and discuss media artifacts in light of who is looking at those artifacts.

Authors