Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

I Said, They Said: The Politics of Representation in Engaged Scholarship

Mon, April 16, 8:15 to 9:35am, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Fourth Floor, East Suite

Abstract

More than ever, schools are under intense pressure to prove their worth, even facing threats of closure and the revocation of their charters. This new political economy of urban education (Lipman 2011)--one characterized by increasingly punitive and austere measures--heightens the stakes of university-school partnerships and raises concerns about how schools are represented by outsiders, including well-intentioned scholars. As schools feel more vulnerable than ever, anything that falls short of a glowing representation is seen as putting them at risk of added scrutiny by district administrators, charter authorizers, and grant foundations. Yet being overly sensitive to these concerns potentially produces sanitized and romanticized portraits of schools. In the attempt to address longstanding imbalances of power between universities and schools, engaged scholars risk compromising the kind of criticality that has made educational research most impactful—that is, critical scholarship that exposes inequality in its many forms (e.g., Anyon 1997). While the politics of representation is an age-old issue in ethnographic research (Brettell 1996; Clifford and Marcus 1986; Jackson 2013), it carries new weight in light of intensified risks to schools. How do engaged scholars navigate the tension between producing critical scholarship that shines a light on inequalities, while remaining sensitive to school partners’ rights over representation?

This paper examines this question through reflecting on my school-based fieldwork as I attempted to both share power over the writing process, and produce critical scholarship. In particular, school leaders took issue with my research question that examined how the school maintained inclusivity for black students in a predominantly Asian-American school. Because of the school’s progressive, anti-racist, and activist orientation, this research question was interpreted as an accusation that the school was engaged in anti-black practices. They felt I had inadequately represented the school and ignored the ways they had thoughtfully incorporated black cultural practices into the school’s curricula and programs. This, they believed, potentially compromised their funding and their charter. As data sources, this paper draws on email exchanges; school leaders’ markup of my dissertation; the revisions that came out of their comments; and notes from a meeting among school leaders, my dissertation committee, and myself. It reflects upon these sources of ethnographic data as a way of seriously problematizing the ruptures of trust that occur in partnerships, and to consider how what we prioritize shapes the kind of engagement and the kind of scholarship that is possible.

Author