Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objective
This design-based research study explores disciplinary literacy practices as supporting urban fourth/fifth graders sense making while engaged in engineering design.
Theoretical Framework
The study explores complex idea development important to learning engineering design – described as sense-making by the Next Generation Science Standards (Schwarz, Passmore, & Reisert, 2017). The goal is to understand relationships between disciplinary literacies and sense making specifically related to three NGSS practices: 6) constructing explanations and designing solutions; 7) engaging in argument from evidence; and 8) obtaining, evaluating and communicating information (NGSS, 2013).
Systemic functional theories of language as outlined by Halliday and Matthiessan (2004), are utilized to align disciplinary practices of engineering with academic language practices important to later elementary levels (ages 9 -12). Practitioners of academic disciplines, including engineering, organize information and build ideas through specific linguistic genres (how a text is organized within a culture to achieve its social purpose) and register features (the lexico-grammar or language specific to the situation within the culture) (Christie, 2008; Fang, 2012). Engineers draw on linguistic as well as semiotic resources as they create, negotiate, critique, and engage with ideas to solve engineering design problems. Visual, material, symbolic as well as linguistic choices create semiotic hybrid texts (Fang, 2012) meaningful in fields such as science, mathematics, and engineering. This study questioned what can students “do” with language and signs in relation to what they “do” with ideas as they make sense of engineering design challenges (Haneda, 2014; Lee, Quinn, & Valdes, 2014).
Methods and Data Sources
Researchers (two engineering educators and one literacy educator) worked with four teachers to develop students’ textual practices in conjunction with teaching engineering units. A four-year iterative process of data collection and analysis reflective of design-based research (Cobb, 2003) analyzed transcribed classroom audio and video, digital engineering notebook files, student writing and other unit-related texts (e.g. posters).
Findings
The original problem was how to create linguistically rich instruction that supported complex idea development important for later elementary engineering learners. Beyond studying technical vocabulary, students historically had little experience producing and utilizing complex texts focused specifically in the disciplines of science and engineering.
The poster will outline theoretical questions, responsive innovations, and ongoing challenges that emerged through research cycles – culminating in a unit where the instruction explicitly focused on textual choices as an active element in solving an engineering challenge. For example, responsive innovations included: 1) developing ipad notebook templates and exploring their affordances for: team collaboration, flexible and multi-modal recording of design decisions, and student-created hybrid documentation of evidence for communicating within and beyond their design team; 2) initial, ongoing, and dialogic instruction in text development clearly related to the specific design challenge, and 3) structuring disciplinary genres of description, explanation, and argument as a process by which students’ extended their reflection.
Scientific or scholarly significance
This study contributes to the emerging literature focused on discourse practices important to engineering education, especially at the elementary level. It also provides a linguistic theory aligned with NGSS practices #6,7,8.
Patricia C. Paugh, University of Massachusetts - Boston
Kristen Wendell, Tufts University
Chelsea Andrews, Tufts University
Christopher George Wright, Drexel University