Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Onto-Epistemic Reimaginings for Service-Learning

Sat, April 14, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Third Floor, Room 3.02-3.03

Abstract

Purpose
In the inaugural issue of the Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning, Giles & Eyler (1994) argued that service-learning was a modern iteration of Dewey’s (1900/1990) problem-based learning. Beyond disciplinary theories, the two believed service-learning needed theorizing to flourish in the academy. Since they leaned on Dewey to articulate a theoretical framework for service-learning, Dewey’s ideas remain central in the literature. This paper explores how Dewey is used in service-learning literature in order to suggest that Dewey’s ideas have been oversimplified to the marginalization of ontology.

Theoretical Framework
Though Dewey refused the separation between episteme (ways of thinking) and ontos (habits of being), service-learning as pedagogy often splits the two. This paper takes up Sheffield’s (2015) call to complicate service-learning beyond “traditional epistemology” in order to understand how service-learning might enact a Deweyan onto-epistemology (p. 47).

Methods and Data
This paper involves archival research that makes visible the use of Dewey in service-learning literature. For example, when Giles & Eyler (1994) cited Dewey in making claims about service-learning, they were alone among their fellow authors to do so. Two years later, almost half of the articles published on service-learning did so; even when not explicitly referenced, Dewey’s ideas remain at the fore. This paper explores how service-learning practitioners borrowed from Dewey certain assumptions of learning, including the idea that knowledge is a process of inquiry based upon students’ interest and reflection (Eyler, 2002) to the benefit of a more democratic citizenry (Bringle & Hatcher, 1996).

Results
In emphasizing these aspects of knowledge, the material world of communities and people is secondary. The use of Dewey in service-learning literature is heavily epistemic. Student learning takes priority over communal relations. This is an incarnation of the Cartesian duality, allowing service-learning to operate as an experience in which students enter communities to gain knowledge. This makes possible the classification of people and communities as Others, leading to a hierarchical system of knowledge. Students learn by experiencing the communities that Others remain confined to. When service-learning classes act as if there is a split between the subject-matter knowledge learned in the classroom and the experiences had at the community placement, a hierarchy is imposed that plays out in harmful ways, limiting possibilities for learning and damaging communities served.

Significance
In interrogating the epistemology of service-learning to show what is made possible and what is silenced in traditional conceptions of the pedagogy, the need for an onto-epistemology of service-learning becomes apparent. Understanding service-learning as an onto-epistemic pedagogy brings the messy labor of being in community to the fore. Texts and teachers are no longer the sole fount of knowledge; being in community is similarly generative. Taking Dewey seriously requires recognizing that the creation of knowledge is a process of inquiry that involves students and communities in a deeply integrative way. Imagining what that would look like requires re-reading Dewey’s theory of learning as an onto-epistemology which invites new possibilities for service-learning.

Author