Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Overview & Objectives
Text from Nasma (all names are pseudonyms): “I’ve started moving my things out of the house (I’m putting it in your office for now).” Thus began the story of how one of the youth I had worked with for four years on various YPAR projects, became homeless and turned to me for help. Entering this crisis with Nasma took time and an emotional toll, and it affected the dynamic of our relationship while finishing a YPAR project.
Youth Participatory Action Research (YPAR) works to rebalance inequitable relationships based on roles, age, race, gender, etc. Providing help to Nasma as she confronted the traumatic situation of homelessness affected our collaborative relationship as she became dependent on me for basic economic resources. Through this process, the inequities in age and material resources between Nasma and I were centered shifting the more equitable interactions that we had constructed through YPAR projects. This paper examines the emotional and epistemological “risks of care” involved in providing material help to youth in crisis.
Theoretical Frameworks
YPAR’s epistemological lineage links to Freire’s critical pedagogy (Cammarota & Fine, 2010). Freire recognized that the liberatory educational endeavor becomes undermined when facilitators solve the problems on behalf of the oppressed, what he called “charity,” because it positions the oppressed as passive recipients rather than historical agents of change (Freire, 1970). I use a Freirean lens to explore the impact of material assistance on the relational collaborations in YPAR.
Methods and Modes of Inquiry
This paper draws on narrative inquiry (Goodall, 2012) recognizing with Sara Worth (2005) that “traditional forms of knowledge (knowing how and knowing that) are not sufficient to cover a third kind of knowledge (knowing what it is like) in the way that storytelling can.” Through sharing a detailed story of the “risks of care,” I seek to engage others in complicating the epistemological realities of conducting research and reconsider the notions of inevitability that often are ignored in the final presentations of research (Bourdieu, 1977; Rosaldo, 1993).
Data Sources
This research draws on field notes, interviews and digital dialogues (emails and text messages between members of the YPAR team) collected during the process of a two year YPAR project. This paper, in particular, focuses on the relational dynamics, particularly in a time of crisis, of the YPAR team and how it affected the process of completing the research.
Results & Significance
The analysis of this story raises more questions than it answers. When we develop long-term caring relationships with the youth with whom we work, we are afforded access to the lived realities that extend beyond the scope of our research, particularly when youth encounter crises. This paper recognizes that how we respond in moments of crisis impacts our relational dynamics. This relational dynamic is central to the epistemological basis of YPAR. Exploring these implications needs to be addressed in the epistemological considerations for YPAR.