Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Hidden Transactions: How School Personnel Shape Public School Choice for Families Across Class Lines

Sat, April 14, 2:15 to 3:45pm, New York Marriott Marquis, Floor: Seventh Floor, Empire/Hudson Room

Abstract

Jean Anyon’s work critiques the notion that education is the solution to economic problems, and argues instead that educational reform needs to be part of a larger social movement that seeks to stimulate and support impoverished urban neighborhoods through sustained, grassroots community organizing. Anyon’s work in this area is timelier than ever as White families and the upper middle-class return to urban areas to (re)claim public schools.

Earlier this summer, U.S. Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos announced that President Trump was “proposing the most ambitious expansion of school choice in our nation’s history.” Researchers and media have confirmed this timely national concern and interest in public school choice and the ongoing need to understand the journeys of families in this complex process (Hannah-Jones, 2016; Makris, 2015; Possey-Maddox, 2014). Class inequities within the school choice process are well documented, however one gap in the literature includes looking at the role of school personnel in aiding families in navigating school choice.

This paper examines how school personnel (principals, guidance counselors, and teachers) activate their networks and use their knowledge and skill sets to aid families in navigating public school admissions – in different ways and with different results. I asked: How do school administrators, teachers and other school personnel play a role in influencing public school choice for students and their families? What happens when abundant private resources influence a public process?

Data sources include field notes from a two year ethnography (1,000 hours) at two public middle-school schools whose families were undergoing the High School Admissions Process. These were the well-resourced, Gracie School in the Upper East Side and the under-resourced, El Barrio Academy in East Harlem. School staff and families were interviewed at each of the schools as well as district administrators (N=80).

Data were analyzed through a theoretical framework based on the work of French sociologist, Pierre Bourdieu; specifically his concepts of social capital, cultural capital, and economic capital. These concepts are braided with Anyon’s theoretical perspective of the political economy of education.

School personnel from both the well-resourced and the under-resourced middle school were actively engaged in supporting families with high school choice. This engagement took place is a number of activities that I call “hidden transactions”, School choice systems are often dependent on school staff, yet school staff in different communities have vastly different orientations and allocated workloads to help navigate the choice process which as a result shapes different experiences for families. Gracie staff is able to accomplish this with their Vigorous Verification of each stage in the school choice process while El Barrio’s attempts (although well-meaning) resulted in Benevolent Betrayals of families who need the most guidance.

It is imperative to view school personnel as classed individuals as this impacts the way they intervene to support families.

Author