Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objectives/Purposes
This paper presents findings from a recent survey of Massachusetts Teacher Educators’ perceptions of, interest in, and implementation of social-emotional learning (SEL) and culturally responsive teaching (CRT) in their respective teacher preparation programs. The MA. Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (ESE) published revised guidelines for the Professional Standards for Teachers (PST). Included under the PST “Teaching All Students” standard, one of the guidelines’ four overarching standards, is both a “cultural proficiency” indicator and a “social and emotional learning” indicator. These indicators, among others, are meant to guide the practice of both pre-service and in-service teachers, through respective alignment with the Candidate Assessment of Performance (CAP) and the MA Educator Evaluation Framework. The overarching purpose of the survey was to explore if and how the SEL and cultural proficiency indicators guide teacher educators in their work with preservice candidates.
Perspective or theoretical framework
A growing body of research indicates that to most optimally support students’ success in school and in life, and for teachers to thrive in their profession, the social-emotional dimensions of learning and teaching must be explicitly integrated into educational systems. Critical to this endeavor is the cultivation of pre-service candidates’ SEL knowledge, skills, and dispositions, throughout teacher preparation program experiences—to help candidates develop emotional resilience and the skills needed to effectively foster social-emotional and cognitive learning within relationally attuned, and culturally responsive classroom environments—to benefit students from a wide range of cultural and socio-economic backgrounds.
Methods and Data Sources
The survey was administered using a secure, anonymous, online tool in early 2017. Respondents were obtained through email sampling, sent to teacher education institutions as well as to the email list of the sponsoring organization. The survey respondents consisted of 76 professionals in teacher education. Of these, 56 were faculty members (73.7%), 11 were deans or administrators (14.5%), and 9 were in other roles such as mentor teachers or supervisors of student teachers (11.8%). Respondents from private institutions of higher education make up 61.8% of the sample, while those from public institutions of higher education account for 34.2%. Others (3.9%) come from K-12 institutions. This paper includes quantitative results, as well as a thematic analysis of the qualitative survey responses. For items with mixed-methods (quantitative and qualitative), responses were examined using a stratified approach, looking at themes and selecting examples within subgroups.
Consequences: Findings and Implications
Attention to SEL and culturally responsive teaching continues to be minimal and piecemeal in the large majority of teacher preparation programs, in MA and across the U.S. To operationalize culturally responsive social-emotional learning in pre-service teacher education, a coordinated, dual bottom-up—top-down approach is necessary. Teacher educators have a key role in how preservice candidates perceive and are guided by state professional teaching standards and indicators (e.g. the cultural proficiency and SEL indicators in MA). Yet, many teacher educators, policy makers, etc. still need to be convinced of the vital importance of culturally responsive social-emotional learning.