Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Translating Metamotivational Awareness Into Behavior

Mon, April 16, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Fifth Floor, Room 5.08

Abstract

Objectives
There is no doubt that self-regulation can be challenging. We propose that what may be especially critical for self-regulatory effectiveness is being able to flexibly shift motivational strategies to meet changing situational demands, given that different situations often require qualitatively distinct types of motivation. Two studies (Scholer & Miele, 2016) address these questions by examining whether individuals have accurate metamotivational beliefs about “task-motivation fit,” or how different types of motivation (e.g., promotion vs. prevention) fit with different tasks (e.g., brainstorming vs. proofreading).

Theoretical Framework
Integrating insights from the metacognition and emotion regulation literatures, the current studies examine whether individuals have accurate metamotivational beliefs about task-motivation fit and whether these beliefs are translated into behavior. We drew upon regulatory focus theory (Higgins, 1997) to test these ideas. The theory is an ideal testing ground because it not only differentiates between two qualitatively distinct orientations (promotion vs. prevention), but there is also evidence for how the particular modes of task engagement (eagerness vs. vigilance) associated with each orientation lead to optimal performance on certain tasks.

Methods and Results
In Study 1, 202 undergraduates were assigned to one of two tasks (brainstorming or proofreading) that are best performed in an eager versus vigilant manner. Participants had to choose to complete the task under a gain-oriented incentive structure (known to induce a promotion orientation) or a loss-oriented incentive structure (known to induce a prevention orientation). They also rated how well they would expect to perform under each incentive structure. Although participants’ mean expectancies reflected accurate beliefs about task-motivation fit (i.e., gain-oriented incentive structure for brainstorming vs. loss-oriented incentive structure for proofreading), F(1, 198)=4.69, p=.03, η2p=.02, behavioral choice reflected a dominant preference for gain-oriented incentives. Participants were more likely to choose the gain-oriented incentives (72%) regardless of task condition (p=.001).
Study 2 examined whether changing the target of choice could increase the likelihood that participants would translate metamotivational beliefs into consequential behavior. Undergraduates (N=228) were assigned to two motivational inductions (one promotion and one prevention) and, for each, had to choose the task they would perform the best at after completing the induction (a task demanding eagerness vs. a task demanding vigilance) and rate their expectancies for each task. As in Study 1, the predicted interaction emerged for expectancies, F(1, 215)=6.99, p=.009, η2p=.03. In addition, the percentage of participants who chose to complete a vigilance task after a prevention induction (59.4%) was significantly above chance (p=.006) and higher than the percentage of participants who chose to complete a vigilance task after a promotion induction (49.8%).

Significance
Drawing on regulatory focus theory, these studies provide evidence that while some individuals exhibit accurate beliefs about task-motivation fit, they may also have competing beliefs about promotion motivation being generally adaptive, regardless of task type. Given this tension, having accurate metamotivational beliefs about task-motivation fit does not always lead to behavioral enactment.

Authors