Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Setting Queer Theory Loose: Addressing Childhood Sexual Innocence in the Age of AIDS

Sun, April 7, 3:40 to 5:10pm, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Floor: 700 Level, Room 710

Abstract

A dominant discursive framing of children as innocent remains a major cul de sac in the development of appropriate pedagogies that address sexuality in the age of AIDS. In early childhood, the framing of children as incapable of feeling, being and thinking gender and sexuality is especially prominent. Childhood sexual innocence is normalised despite recognition that growing children are active makers of their social worlds. Children are not simply passively waiting for a specific time in life to address gender and sexuality. But, when the normative understanding of childhood insists on children’s lack of sexual agency, a paradox is created between what children actually know and do and the fallacy of sexual innocence. One common solution to this is to deny childhood sexuality. This paper argues that in the age of AIDS children are short-changed by discourses of childhood innocence which functions as a relation of power which normalises children’s sexual innocence. In the context of the pressing risk to HIV, we still assume that children are too young to understand sexual knowledge (Silin 1995). Young children remain “too quiet for us to hear, too small for us to see … that they fall beneath our threshold of attention” (Tobin 1997: 13). Childhood innocence and the need for child protection justify silence and adult inaction around effective sexuality and AIDS education. The price of innocence, I argue, is the continued inattention and neglect to children’s own conceptualisations and experience of the disease. By setting in motion the paradox between adult narratives of childhood innocence and children’s meanings of AIDS, the paper deploys queer theorising to oppose everyday common sense assumptions that question the aptness of putting children and sexuality together (Tobin 1997). The utility of queer theorising is the recognition that children interpret, shape and negotiate meanings of the disease within their local contexts as they expand, explore and elaborate upon their gendered/(hetero)sexual selves. An understanding of children’s AIDS-related sexual knowledge requires a fine-grained analysis of the social, material and discursive forces through which such meanings are made and a critical appreciation of children’s agency in promoting and negotiating them. The paper reiterates the need for attention to young children’s knowledge of AIDS, in their own right, in order to unravel the knot that has developed in defence of childhood sexual innocence. In particular, queer theorising summons us as adults to re-think our special responsibility to children in the time of AIDS and to shed our taken-for-granted assumptions about childhood sexual innocence, so that we can develop the kind of pedagogies that open our understanding to the creative ways in which children give meaning to AIDS, gender, sexuality and relations of power.

Author