Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Professionalization of Teachers Within the Internationals Network for Public Schools

Sat, April 6, 10:25 to 11:55am, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Floor: 200 Level, Room 201B

Abstract

Objectives or purposes: Teaching has never been a highly esteemed profession in the US. Recent macro-level phenomena have further diminished the status of teaching. In particular, the era of high-stakes testing has allowed external entities to expand their reach over schools, leaving teachers with considerably less influence over instruction and curricular materials, assessment practices, school schedules, class size and composition, teaching assignments, budgetary decisions, and disciplinary practices (Ingersoll, 2007; Pace & Hemmings, 2007). Internationals Network schools utilize a unique set of practices that re-professionalize teachers by positioning them as experts of pedagogy and curriculum. Using a comparative case study design, this paper compares professional practices in place in Internationals Network schools with those of non-Network schools in order to understand the how these practices contribute to the professionalization of teachers.

Perspective(s) or theoretical framework: In an analysis of how teaching compares to other occupations on a range of characteristics associated with professional work, including credentialing, induction of new members, professional development opportunities, degree of specialization, decision-making authority, compensation, and prestige, Ingersoll and Merrill (2011) determine that teaching “continues to be treated as…a ‘semi-profession’” (Ingersoll & Merrill, 2011, p. 194). I use the framework outlined by Ingersoll and Merrill (2011) to understand how schools within the Internationals are able to elevate the status of teachers by re-positioning them as experts on curriculum and pedagogy.

Methods: This paper draws upon data collected as part of a three-year study of how schools can address inequities in educational outcomes among high-needs immigrant youth, which includes qualitative case studies in four New York City high schools. The four school sites include two schools within the Internationals Network which exclusively serve recently arrived immigrants as well as two comparison schools that serve a similar population of students. Case studies include ethnographic observation of professional meetings, classroom instruction, assessment, and school events as well as interviews and focus groups with school leaders, administrators, school support staff, and teachers. Through observation and interviews, we examine if and how the school model used by Internationals facilitates the professionalization of teachers through various professional practices including innovative teacher assessment and evaluation; structured time for teacher collaboration and planning; and professional development among others.

Results: Preliminary results suggest that the Internationals Network has repositioned teachers as professionals through a number of mechanisms including a sophisticated system of leadership distribution and a professional culture in which teachers internalize a sense of responsibility for student outcomes and make key decisions around curricula and instruction.

Scientific or scholarly significance of the study or work: Scholarship on the professionalization of teachers suggests that as professionalization increases, so will the motivation and performance of teachers. This, in turn, will positively impact student learning. (Darling-Hammond 1995; NCES, 1997). Evidence suggests that various aspects of professionalization do, indeed, lead to improved teacher commitment (NCES, 1997). This research makes an important contribution to the literature in this area by examining which school-level practices contribute to teacher professionalization.

Author