Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Undercommons as Resistance to Post-Truth in High School Art Rooms

Sat, April 6, 12:20 to 1:50pm, Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Floor: Second Floor, Wentworth

Abstract

According to scholar of rhetorical theory Bruce McComiskey (2017), “post-truth signifies a state in which language lacks any reference to facts, truths, and realities” (p. 6). Aaron Kuntz (2015) observes a parallel elision of truth in educational research as the practice of methodological technocracy: methodology that meticulously follows procedures in such a way that theory is not foundational to knowledge production. Materialism or marxism, for example, may be referenced in a project without them impacting the research process and, therefore, are functionally interchangeable with other theories. Thus, methodological technocrats implement precise methods but make no truth claims. Kuntz posits that truth requires a deeper engagement with theory. Scholarship that does not acknowledge truth ignores the operations of power and, as such, tacitly supports hegemony. The hegemony of concern in this paper is that within public high schools.

In public schools the relativism enabled by post-truth mindsets makes vulnerable students more vulnerable. Telling a hungry student that their stomach pain is a symptom of anxiety is an example of post-truth in action, as are deficit approaches to exceptional learners (Hardy & Woodcock, 2015) and other diverse groups. Such perspectives locate problems of under achievement in individuals while denying clear and measurable societal causes for students’ struggling. One example of such a societal cause is the more frequent rates of expulsion among black students when compared to non-black students who have broken the same rules (Author, in press; Edwards, 2016; Woodbury, 2016)

This paper is a close reading of Stefano Harney and Fred Moten’s (2013) book, The undercommons: Fugitive planning and black study, and a translation of this work to public high school art contexts. The purpose of this paper is to employ the undercommons as an epistemic device or a way of seeing and knowing from the perspective of marginalized students. Following Kuntz’s (2015) call to resist methodological technocracy with “inquiry [that] engages in social justice work through risky practices of truth-telling” (pp. 93-94), this writing roots truth in the perspective of the undercommons, a conceptual space created by social bonds between individuals who are excluded from common resources (Harney & Moten, 2013). Common resources here are defined as what legal scholar Dean Spade (2015) refers to as life chances, or factors which affect longevity: “housing, education, health care, identity documentation and records, employment, and public facilities, to name but a few” (p. xii).

I review several key ideas from The undercommons (Harney & Moten, 2013) including specialized definitions and functions of undercommons, study, planning, policy, fugitivity, and antagonism. These concepts, translated to public high school contexts (Author, in press), make student activism and survival strategies visible in ways that avoid the conventional misinterpretations of student behaviour, which are biased toward finding faults. Rooting truth through the undercommons allows for the development of art education pedagogy which provides refuge for vulnerable students and enables resistance to oppressive hegemonies enabled by post-truth mindsets.

Author