Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Celling Sex: Harm Reduction Practices of Young Women Engaged in Transactional Sex in Toronto, Canada

Sat, April 6, 12:20 to 1:50pm, Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Floor: Second Floor, Wentworth

Abstract

In the post-truth era, there is moral panic over young people, the Internet, human trafficking, and the criminalization of adolescent sexual activity (e.g., sexting). This public narrative risks eroding accessible services for women and girls and their right to control their sexualized bodies. Celling Sex is a community-based research study using cellphilm method to engage young women who trade sex. It explores their definitions and approaches to harm reduction, HIV and AIDS prevention, and health care access. Young women’s rights to make decisions about their bodies are highlighted to center their experiences and knowledge, while also critically engaging with the types of daily risks that they take. In this paper, I explore the cellphilm method to center young women in the research process and to disrupt post-truth narratives by supporting young women to enter and lead discussions on public health and community responses to transactional sex in Toronto, Canada.

Participatory visual methodologies are established modes of studying women’s health, sexual education, and HIV prevention. Drawing on community-based health research principles, they are used to conduct research with communities. Cellphilms are participant-produced videos made with mobile technology in response to a research question or prompt. Cellphilm data is analyzed in a participatory manner and the cellphilms are often integrated into community engagement and knowledge translation activities. Using a technology that participants already use to document and represent their lives, cellphilm method builds on existing media literacy skills and contributes to participants’ control over the research process and results.

The study engages young women (ages 16-25) living in Toronto who engage in transactional relationships (e.g., escorting, finessing). During one-on-one cellphilm workshops, participants created cellphilms that gave insights into their transactional relationships and harm reduction practices. The cellphilms were analyzed collaboratively by the research team and participants. Cellphilm screenings engaged diverse community stakeholders in constructive dialogue about the needs and supports available to young women who trade sex.

The cellphilms outline harm reduction practices, with a focus on how they use their cellphones when they interact with partners. Sex is not necessarily the central component of these relationships, suggesting that the transactional concept is perhaps misdirected and contributes to a sense of moral panic. That said, girls do take great risks to meet with men in exchange for money or commodities. These exchanges are analyzed within their lived experience of limited access to education and employment, citizenship status, racialization, gender, and sexuality.

This study focuses on the Canadian context. The participants’ cellphilms are multi-faceted, and raise several understudied questions about transactional sex practices in Canada within larger systems of oppression, which influence young women’s employment, access to education, and sense of agency and self-determination. The results of this project inform health services and community support of young women. The use of cellphilm method is argued to be particularly relevant as an accessible strategy to engage with this diverse community.

Author