Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Ethnographic Cross-Examination: Cultural Inquiry and the Contentious Pursuit of Truth

Mon, April 8, 12:20 to 1:50pm, Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Floor: Second Floor, Civic Ballroom South

Abstract

Objectives

This paper addresses the extent to which law professor Steven Lubet's (2018) advocacy of cross-examination is relevant to ethnographic research in schools. In Interrogating Ethnography, Lubet draws heavily on the strategies of the legal trial to illuminate how ethnography fails to incorporate “cross-examinations” of evidence. However, the cultural worlds that are the focus of ethnographies are decidedly different from crime scenes. In this paper, the author compares the pursuit of “truth” in ethnography with what is sought after in a legal trial. Ultimately, important distinctions exist between what matters in a courtroom and what matters in a culture.

Perspectives

Cross-examination is a core component of the administration of justice. Lawyers aim to convince jurors of the veracity of their narratives, and their arguments are subjected to intensive scrutiny from professional opposition. Similar to the proverbial court case, ethnographers weigh evidence to string together a cohesive account of events in a social world. Rarely, however, are ethnographers compelled to directly address competing claims about their findings. Lubet’s (2017) Interrogating Ethnography questions the credibility of a methodology averse to scholarly dispute. Lubet contends that, among other courtroom practices, cross-examination could sharpen ethnographic descriptions prone to misrepresentations of reality.

Methodology

The author addresses two methodological innovations in ethnography that might represent forms of cultural cross-examination appropriate to the discipline: Michael Burawoy’s (2009) extended case method and Matthew Desmond’s (2014) relational ethnography.

To further engage ethnography’s disciplinary potential for cross-examination, the author considers the culture of poverty thesis. In many respects, the development of the scholarly debate regarding culture of poverty involves the cross-examination of ethnography as theorists have attempted to nuance or refute this concept. In particular, the paper addresses the discussion as it unfolds among Oscar Lewis’ (1968), La Vida, Paul Willis’ (1977) Learning to Labour and Annette Lareau’s (2003) Unequal Childhoods. The debates between these works and, in some instances, within the works themselves offer conceptual cross-examinations of a theoretical framework of poverty. The author suggests ways that ethnographic cross-examinations—by way of extended case method and relational ethnography—might be more rigorously applied in ethnographies that engage this theoretical debate.

Findings

The author argues that, dutifully applied, the extended case method and relational ethnography represent a means by which ethnographers can engage in sophisticated cross examination of evidence. In engaging these ideas, the author addresses how Burawoy's extended case method and Desmond’s relational ethnography address the challenges of reliability that Lubet contends are endemic to ethnographic research.

Significance

The methodological argument presented in this paper nuances an important conversation regarding evidence in and for qualitative inquiry. Learning from the practices of other disciplines is an important step in enhancing the strength of one’s own. Lubet’s argument—that vigorous cross-examination is a process by which “steel sharpens steel” to enhance sociological analysis—can certainly benefit educational ethnographies. However, educational ethnographers must harness the tools consistent with disciplinary ideals to construct a more solid foundation of scholarly inquiry.

Author