Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Registraion, Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Objectives
The author explores the role of ethnography to inform evidence-based policy. The paper first discusses epistemological, methodological, and axiological issues underpinning debates about evidence in ethnography and policy-relevant research. The author incorporates arguments posited in two books, Steven Lubet’s (2018) Interrogating Ethnography and Howard Becker’s (2017) Evidence. Focusing on the significance of community members and contextual knowledge, evidence, and interpretations, the author then argues for the utility of ethnographic research to improve policy designs. The paper concludes with a discussion of major issues to consider when using ethnography to inform policy.
Perspective
Ethnography, as a perspective, process and product, enables scholars to examine the experiences of underrepresented cultural groups, to examine how they define and make sense of reality (Agar 1980; Wolcott, 1995). The methodology has important implications for policy design and implementation (Datnow, 2006; Honig, 2004). Nevertheless, research trends—such as how government agencies and federal laws define rigorous research—have demonstrated education stakeholders’ preference for experimental and quasi-experimental research (Lather, 2004; St. Pierre, 2006).
Adopting a constructivist approach to policy design (Fischer, 2003), the author argues that the narrow definition of evidence-based policy limits the utility of research to inform and support policy design in context. Evidence-based policy is “the application of rigorous research methods, particularly randomized controlled trials (RCTs), to build credible evidence about “what works” to improve the human condition” (Baron, 2018, p. 40). The definition fails to incorporate diverse epistemological and axiological views—and underlying values and assumptions—of methods, evidence, and evaluation.
Methodology
The paper incorporates scholarship pertaining to the foundations of ethnography and evidence-based policy. The author intersperses methodological discussions with examples of urban ethnography, including the monographs Lubet (2018) identified and reviewed.
Findings
Ethnography and evidence-based policy include different and often contradictory assumptions, values, and methods. A key obstacle to current methodological debates is the focus on generalizable knowledge and effort to decouple evidence from settings. Discussions of evidence fail to appreciate different forms of knowledge including episteme, techne, and phronesis (Flyvbjerg, 2001). Crudely stated for the purposes of the proposal, episteme pertains to “universal, invariable, and context-free” knowledge. Phronesis, in contrast, is “pragmatic, variable, and context-dependent” knowledge (p.57). Whereas episteme most closely aligns with current definitions of policy-relevant research, phronesis, which focuses on the ethical application of knowledge in context, connects to the major tenets of ethnographic inquiry. Each approach necessarily alters how one defines evidence and its role towards conducting and establishing trustworthy scholarship.
Significance
To dismiss ethnography as untrustworthy or, worse, unscientific, ignores the rich history of the methodology and its potential to inform policy designs. To some, ethnography and evidence-based policy may be at odds. Ethnography invites polyvocal accounts with multiple explanations to phenomenon; evidence-based policy, as currently defined, prizes experimental and quasi-experimental research designs that produce clear, actionable findings. The author, in contrast, asserts that ethnography has a necessary role for the production of policy-relevant research. Scholars, however, must understand the methodology’s strengths, weaknesses, and possibilities.